There are 147 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

The Most Overated/Underated Niners

Underated
1.Shawntae Spencer
2.Manny Lawson
3.Joe Nedney

Overated
1. Eric Heitmann
2. Michael Lewis
3. Issac Sopaga

Feel free to give some insight... God Bless
3.
considering ninertalk lately,

overrated - Nate Davis, he is definitely talented but there is no need to rush another young quarterback into action before they are ready.

underrated - Michael Robinson, considering people are treating him as some kind of pariah for the likes of Thomas Clayton and Kory Sheets he is certainly under appreciated.
i think Jason Hill and Delanie Walker are pretty underrated.
overrated i think Nate Davis and Mike Lewis
Overrated: Alex Smith

Underrated: Alex Smith
Originally posted by blunt_probe:
Overrated: Alex Smith

Underrated: Alex Smith

Nicely done.
Originally posted by NickSh49:
Originally posted by blunt_probe:
Overrated: Alex Smith

Underrated: Alex Smith

Nicely done.
Originally posted by chico49erfan:
Originally posted by NickSh49:
Originally posted by blunt_probe:
Overrated: Alex Smith

Underrated: Alex Smith

Nicely done.

  • bobbyblackjack
  • Info N/A
49'er and NFL Great BILL ROMANOWSKI will be LIVE on Talking Football LIVE this Friday, January 29. The show runs from 2-4pm ET and is heard on WIFI 1460AM in New Jersey. The show can be heard in the San Francisco area on www.wifi1460am.com. Call in and talk to Marcus or your hosts about any NFL topic!!! Call-in number is 347-884-8215.
Overrated: Josh Morgan.

Underrated: Jason Hill.
overrated: crabtree

underrated: Franklin
  • crzy
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,284
Overrated: Alex Smith, Joe Staley

Underrated: Takeo Spikes
Overrated: Shaun Hill...just ask Iron Mike, if you don't believe me...

Underrated: John York...and pretty much everybody believes he deserves to be...
Over-rated: Nate Clements

Under-rated: Justin Smith
Originally posted by bobbyblackjack:
49'er and NFL Great BILL ROMANOWSKI will be LIVE on Talking Football LIVE this Friday, January 29. The show runs from 2-4pm ET and is heard on WIFI 1460AM in New Jersey. The show can be heard in the San Francisco area on www.wifi1460am.com. Call in and talk to Marcus or your hosts about any NFL topic!!! Call-in number is 347-884-8215.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Overrated: Josh Morgan.

Underrated: Jason Hill.

Right on the money!

Also How is Sopoaga overrated???