Starters Report Card for 2009 Season By Meccaniner

Great idea for a post, very bad grading criteria. No "A" for Willis? Come on man, did you watch any games?

Originally posted by meccaniner:
Defense
Shawntae Spencer A-
Justin Smith B+
Patrick Willis B+ Hes compared to Ray Lewis in his prime...didnt play to that level
Dashon Goldson B
Aubrayo Franklin B
Manny Lawson B-
Issac Sopoaga C
Takeo Spikes C
Parys Haralson D
Michael Lewis D
Nate Clements F

Offense
Vernon Davis A Fulfilling his God given potential
Michael Crabtree B ...Future niner Star
Alex Smith C+.....The Phoenix has risen
Frank Gore C.....Time to draft replacement?
Moran Morris D ...he plays ?....not a factor


Josh Morgan D...... Not a starting caliber Wr...Hill should start
Joe Staley D Disappointing performance and injury
David Bass D
Eric Heitmann D A constant liability for 6+years
Chilo Rachal D ....Will get better
Adam Snyder F..... Complete failure

Patrick Willis got 49 out of a possible 50 votes for All Pro MLB and you gave him a B+? You have no idea what the f**k you are talking about, do you? I won't even get into the rest of your ridiculous grades.

Just when MeccaNiner was gaining some cred, he completely blows it all with this.

Im a hard grader...I know. Willis get all the attention, and fans think he is the next Ray lewis...so he must be graded the hardest. must expect perfection from him

Originally posted by meccaniner:
Defense
Shawntae Spencer A-
Justin Smith B+
Patrick Willis B+ Hes compared to Ray Lewis in his prime...didnt play to that level
Dashon Goldson B
Aubrayo Franklin B
Manny Lawson B-
Issac Sopoaga C
Takeo Spikes C
Parys Haralson D
Michael Lewis D
Nate Clements F

Offense
Vernon Davis A Fulfilling his God given potential
Michael Crabtree B ...Future niner Star
Alex Smith C+.....The Phoenix has risen
Frank Gore C.....Time to draft replacement?
Moran Morris D ...he plays ?....not a factor


Josh Morgan D...... Not a starting caliber Wr...Hill should start
Joe Staley D Disappointing performance and injury
David Bass D
Eric Heitmann D A constant liability for 6+years
Chilo Rachal D ....Will get better
Adam Snyder F..... Complete failure

Clements is far from an F. sing is an F for cutting our return man and putting him back their for returns and ending his season. Clements is by far the best tackling CB we have and he hits like a linebacker. He is a B to B- in coverage. He's not Darrell Revis but look around the NFL and who is? His problem issues are vastly overstated on this WZ. Nate is a good CB. Maybe not great but so much better than the trash we have had over the years playing back there.

I agree 100% Morgan is not a starter. Hill should start. All Morgan ever does is tip the ball up into the air for interceptions, drop the ball and get caught from behind. That is when he is not complaining about the ball coming down like a punt. I have no idea what Singletary sees in him.

Heitmann is not a D... He's surrounded by 2 Guards who are D/F players and that makes him look bad. Staley is not as disappointing as a D... It's not his fault he got hurt. It happens. The NFL is rough.

Frank Gore a C... Michael Lewis was mostly injured. Although not great he is decent when healthy.

Originally posted by meccaniner:
Defense
Shawntae Spencer A-
Justin Smith B+
Patrick Willis B+ Hes compared to Ray Lewis in his prime...didnt play to that level
Dashon Goldson B
Aubrayo Franklin B
Manny Lawson B-
Issac Sopoaga C
Takeo Spikes C
Parys Haralson D
Michael Lewis D
Nate Clements F

Offense
Vernon Davis A Fulfilling his God given potential
Michael Crabtree B ...Future niner Star
Alex Smith C+.....The Phoenix has risen
Frank Gore C.....Time to draft replacement?
Moran Morris D ...he plays ?....not a factor


Josh Morgan D...... Not a starting caliber Wr...Hill should start
Joe Staley D Disappointing performance and injury
David Bass D
Eric Heitmann D A constant liability for 6+years
Chilo Rachal D ....Will get better
Adam Snyder F..... Complete failure

LOL FAIL.

VD is an A? led the NFL in penalties AND drops, and was a poor blocker.

Gore is a C? he ran for 1100 yds and scored 13 td's in a passing offensive with horrible run blocking.

Justin Smith is a B+? he was statistically the BEST DE in the NFL this year. didnt know that was only good for a B+...

Willis a B+? again, being the best ILB in the NFL is apparently not good enough...

Dashon Goldson B? he was statistically the WORST cover S in the NFL. the WORST. and he missed alot of tackles.

Takeo Spikes C-? he was statistically a top 5 ILB this season.

Parys Haralson a D-? 6 sacks, 10 qb hits, 27 qb hurries. one of the better pass rushing 3-4 OLBs....

Eric Heitmann a D? hes our only solid run and pass blocking OL. look at the stats dude, hes not top 10, but hes top 15. been so for years. hes a very solid NFL C.

what does this tell us? you know NOTHING about this team, and did NO statistical research whatsoever. you just made yourself look awful dude. lost any credibility.

Sorry to say this, but those grades are pathetic.

Smith and Willis were the two best defensive players this year. End of story.

WTF!!!?????

wow.

wow.


[ Edited by brandonjg on Jan 23, 2010 at 00:06:18 ]

Originally posted by meccaniner:
Im a hard grader...I know. Willis get all the attention, and fans think he is the next Ray lewis...so he must be graded the hardest. must expect perfection from him

then how the f**k did vd get an A!?!

cocaine is a helluva drug

oh look

another person wanting attention

worst analysis ever

Originally posted by brandonjg:
wow.

wow.