Originally posted by ninerfan818:Originally posted by darkknight49:Originally posted by ninerfan818:Originally posted by OnTheClock:Originally posted by ninerfan818:Originally posted by backontop:Originally posted by ninerfan818:Originally posted by backontop:Originally posted by Memphis9er:Originally posted by solidg2000:
Alex Smith! You either love him, or love to hate him!
Not true, I am on the fence about him, he has looked awesome at times this year and then terrible at others. I realize however that he has had no continuity and a couple of people that know more about football than most everyone here (Mike McCarthy and Steve Young) say that is a big deal. Since he is going to be the starter next year anyways, I suggest that people learn to deal with it and quit whining like little girls about it.
It won't ever happen. Some people hate Smith like he raped their mother and they had to grow up with the rape child as their sister which they were strangely attracted too.
you've got issues to even come up with stuff like this. Damn smith supporters...lock this one up.
Damn Smith haters ban them all for lack of logic and rational thinking.
Yah my logic is horrible in me thinking that a qb that has a 3-5 record, terrible stats, almost as much interceptions as TD's, very low completion average, and among the league worst on third down is not responsible for the teams pathetic offense. It must be the offensive lines fault huh...
Where is your reasoning or "logic" for defending this perrenial loser. Ohhhh...let's start the excuses...coordinators, lack of continuity, yada yada yada. None of that is responsible for him having horrible footwork, poor vision, bad accuracy under pressure and not being able to read a defense or a blitz after 5 years in the NFL. That is 5 years of QB meetings regardless and he still doesn't get it, either do you I guess.
If not for his safety valve VD and that seam route he is a joke. You defenders of the Smith always want to fall back on excuses. Everyone can make excuses but it doesn't make you any better. If he was a good QB he would overcome some obstacles, he doesn't. His supporters just use them as excuses. Smith sucks for realz...
That is an absolutely ridiculous statement and you know it.
That's like saying any good QB with a good primary target is "a joke" without them.
Because VD is so quick it is almost a gimme. If he gets off the line clean with a little room is is usually a completion. He doesn't throw many other patterns with much accuracy or success is my point. He can throw a tight end post. Yay. His other throws are mostly off target requiring the receivers to be acrobats to catch them.
Shouldnt a QB have a route they can rely on? You're basically saying no, he shouldnt. Montana lived off that quick slant. Warner and the Rams had thier Dig route.
So what if VD and Smith live off the seam route. Thats a good thing. Of course, they need to develop more routes (which has been a deep hook recently) next year, but you have to start somewhere.
But again it is a question going into YEAR 6. Will he be better. He clearly isn't any better than he ever was now. What has he learned/accomplished? Regardless he has had 5 years of NFL meetings/practices and so on he should be able to complete a myriad of routes in his sleep. But he cannot.
Smith is going into his 6th season and yet this will be the first time he will have the same OC for more than one year. That is pretty much like going through your rookie season 5 years in a row. Oh thats right out of 5 seasons he has only played maybe a total of 3 seasons worth of games due to an injury he suffered from the poor OLine performance that he has had to endure his entire career.
im in!
