Originally posted by nvchamp9ers:
I notice that LA knocks Alex Smiths mechanics and his footwork, as well of his reading of coverage...LA you been around alot and have made it known in the Parking Lot of your situation, so I am wondering what makes it so that you can grade a players technique and mechanics? If you could break down the flaws in his footwork and the flaws in his reading of coverage I would be more than happy to see it. Could you please also include what he needs to do to fix them as well as break down the coverages he retouinely has trouble reading? You are seeing something that I dont, but I am busy with my real job so maybe you could enlighten me since people who have never had any experience in high level football know so much?
I don't see why it's so difficult for someone who doesn't have any experience in high level football to acquire knowledge about fundamentals.
Regarding his footwork, IMO, he struggles in terms of "exploding" out from under center and getting his feet set. This costs him time. Good QBs get to the proper throwing position quicker than he does, from my observation, which I admit could be wrong. I don't think that his first step with his right foot is big enough. I don't think his hip movement is quick enough in his first step either. As for what can be done to fix that, it can either be improving leg strength, or simple repetition, depends on the player. I think it's probably the latter in his case. He's awkward at best. He doesn't have to worry about this when he's in the Shotgun, so this flaw is masked.
I never comment on a QB's ability to read coverage, because I can't see it on TV. Don't know where you got that from.
I don't think he does a good job of feeling where the rush is coming from, and buying time.
I don't think he uses his eyes well and has a tendency to stare receivers down. This is why, in my observation, you see the CB and ball often arriving at the same time. Rich Gannon was all over him for doing this vs. Tennessee.
We'd have to watch a game together in order to argue specific plays and cite specific examples. That being said, I don't know why you think that the basic fundamentals are such a mystery to all but those who work in the sport.
[ Edited by LA9erFan on Nov 22, 2009 at 4:31 PM ]