Originally posted by WillistheWall:Originally posted by Afrikan:Originally posted by xx49erfanxx:Originally posted by jimmythegreekjr:Why are we still chatting about the back up QB....
Shaun Hill's 8 wins as starter of the 49ers since last year:
3 of them against the RAMs, 2 of those at home - the RAMS finished 2-14 2008 and are 1-8 this year, In one of those victories we beat the rams by only 1 point and one of those Kyle Boller was the QB.
1 against Seattle at home this season. Seneca Wallace QB - (Hassleback got hurt) - Seattle finished 4-12 last year, and are 3-6 this year.
1 against the Redskins at home in 2008 who finished the season 8-8 and did not make playoffs.
1 home game against the jets in 2008 - Jets did not make the playoffs in 2008
1 against Buffalo on the road in 2008, Bills finished 7-9, did not make playoffs - they are 3-6 this year.. Hill passed 14-23, 161 yards and the offense scored only 10 points. - This was a defensive win.
1 road game against Arizona this year - first game of the season, Arizona was obviously flat and beat themselves - made a lot of mistakes. Cardinals finished 9-7 last year and went to the Superbowl.
As a matter of fact all of Shaun Hill's 6 losses from last year and this year have been against teams who finished 8-8 or above last year and/or who are above .500 this year
Of the six losses (yes including Houston ), 5 were on the road.
simple...the current starter is not getting the job done, like some said he was going to do if he ever got the chance....
if Alex was playing well and we were winning games....I would doubt a thread like this would get started.......just like when Shaun was playing well last year and early this year...there were no Alex threads started.
People started Alex threads early this year because even in the wins Shaun was playing poorly. Be fair. Don't sugar coat your guy's case just to try to make the other guy who you hate look bad. And if you want to say we were winning games when Shaun was QB and not to talk about Alex, how about acknowledge that Alex just won a game playing nearly the exact same way Hill has? Hill lost 3 of his last 4 anyway.
This is one of the dumbest arguments I think I ever heard... Shaun wasn't getting it done and lost 3 of his last 4. Now, Alex wins a game the same way Shaun had won a few earlier this year; but, Alex is great for it and Hill sucks because of it...
Guess what, Alex hasn't lost lost 3 of his last 4... He's lost 6 of his last 7. Face it, both these guys are not that good.