Originally posted by tohara3:
Makes a big difference what kind team you go to.
I don't buy this argument in a few cases in this league. When Vince Young was drafted by the Titans, they sucked. When Matt Ryan was drafted by ATL, they sucked.
Vince Young has the running talent to make an immediate impact on a team whereas Alex was not a runner like Vince Young. Young was basically an extension of the running game.
Matt Ryan is slightly different in that he had a very solid run-game. However, Gore wasn't exactly chop liver for Smith but our passing game was literally non-existent at key parts of games, even in 2006.
The better team case can be made for BAL rookie QB.