Originally posted by fryet: He has, of course, had better 4th quarter winning drives, but as a whole, that is by far the best I have seen Alex Smith play. My only complaints were the following:
1. The one short pass that I saw him throw, he missed (probably was better that he missed it, but still makes you wonder)
2. Lots of delay of game penalties. Hopefully being the starter will mitigate that in the future (it wouldn't surprise me if Crabtree was guilty of illegal substitution, but that is just me guessing)
#2 should be easily corrected. #1 is an area that we will continue to have to watch as fans. But if he just continues to throw down the field, and ignores the short passes, I don't think we will care that much. (:
I think Smith threw it out of bounds, then Gore looked at him to see what he was doing. Smith pointed at the incoming defender that was about to crack Gore. You see the defender sprinting from the left of the screen.
If he threw it directly to Gore, Gore probably woulda caught it but consider: 1) minimal yardage, 2) staying in bounds, 3) massive hit.
It was the only play he could have made.
Oct 27, 2009 at 11:56 AM
Originally posted by SybErkRimInAL: easily his finest game thus far.
I hope Alex does well but they need to keep on running and spot the passing enough to keep the constant pass rush off. It sure appeared that his accuracy is much better but they need to make sure it does not degrade by getting him sacked a lot. I really think Singletary blew it by keeping too many recievers and not enough runningbacks.
When you run as much as Singletary wanted to, several mediocre recievers are as useful as carbuncles. I also think they need to spot Bruce only for say third downs when his experience would help and let guys like Jones and Jason Hill play. I think next year if they have no injuries they go with Crabtree, Morgan, Jones and Hill and possibly Ziegler and thats it. I think after our crucial picks like safety, Pass rusher and OL they should hit runningbacks and dbs. I think they need another top ten back for sure and Michael Robinson and Norris need to go. I really liked that converted LB fullback. I think he had a hell of a lot to do with the running in preseason. He might seem raw to Singletary but he performs and doesn't f^&^ up. Singletary has some Nolan in him in that he would wear suspenders, belt and safety pins to keep his pants on. He needs to rely less on scrub vets and risk some young studs.
By the numbers there are 9 no votes. I see a lot of people picking at some parts of his performance, but no one states a time and place that he looked better. I seriously hope this type performance can happen again, I see no reason why not. Who cares that the Texans weren't prepared for him, he was making accurate throws, avoiding sacks, and making good decisions. As an ex Smith hater I will even allow him an excuse for some bad clock management. The only mistakes he seemed to make came from rust. Big test coming up Sunday. The Colts now have a defense and can put up points. If he throws for 200 plus and has 2 turnovers or less, I think he is well on his way to being a top notch NFL Qb. GO ALEX!
Oct 27, 2009 at 2:37 PM
Naked bootleg night against the Seachickens... that was his best game. Remember Frank the Tank walking into his interview afterward and telling the fans to expect big things from #11?
Oct 27, 2009 at 2:39 PM
Originally posted by DJD: I've never seen him look so relaxed, read his progressions, make such accurate passes, all over the place. Easily the best ive seen him look.
Were we running a spread to catch up or was that part of the entire game plan? That's where I'm confused. I watched it live and had no idea that was the spread offense.
The Seachickens 2nd half was one to remember. The entire offense stinked in the rain for the first half. It was horrid. In the second half, out came a blazing Alex Smith. He did everything well that game.
I think this last half trumps the Seahawks game because he had no reps during the week and hadn't played a meaningful game in over 2 years. I can't remember the last time a QB looked so poised and delivered so many nice balls.
What I like the most about the last game was how much Smith seemed that he was in charge.
This fan site is dedicated to the 49ers and their fans. It is in no way affiliated with the NFL or any of its teams. All teams and players mentioned on this site are registered trademarks of the NFL. The use of any team names, words, trademarks, logos or photos have been used for descriptive purposes only. The content and information from other sites is the property of their respective owners. Player and team photos used with permission from USA TODAY Sports Images.