Originally posted by NinerGM:Originally posted by PatrickJira411:
We were not very well prepared to play this game, pathetic coming out of a bye the way we opened up and really the whole game, poor clock managment, bad penalty's, just sloppy. Im starting to question if Singletary is a good HC. I know he does a good job of motivating these guys but obviously we do not have a good X's and O's coaching staff and the bad clock managment and use of timeouts reminds me of the Nolan days...
Okay lets start at QB, Shuan Hill was obviously a big problem and slowed the offense down. I know backup QB's usually come in and have some success as the oppossing teams have not prepared for that guy and the Texans did play soft in coverage for the most part but it is obvious Alex Smith is a better QB than Shuan Hill. He can make throws down the field, I mean Shuan Hill is useless if the team is down by more than 10pts as he cannot move the ball down the field.
I thought Alex Smith played pretty dam well. He made a few really, really nice throws down the field and also did a nice job of stepping up when he had pressure on him and making the throw. Now, can he keep this up now that teams know he is our QB? We'll see, but I am a lot more excited/confident with Alex Smith as our QB going down the stretch than I am if Shuan Hill was.
Vernon Davis- The guy is now a pro bowl player. He is so deadly over the middle and he and Alex Smith seem to have a chemistry. VD has finally arrived as a premier tight end in this league and a legit playmaker.
Michael Crabtree- Amazing! I was expecting this kid to play 20-25 snaps and have a catch or two and instead he played in what? 50 snaps and he had 5 catches for 58yds and three of those catches were really nice. This kid is going to be special, really reminds me of Michael Irvin out there.
Josh Morgan- Stepped up, much better suited to play in the slot and Crabtree is going to make him better and better.
O-Line: They did a decent job in the 2nd half pass blocking as the Texans knew we were throwing as they were going all out as pass rushers. Rachal played awful and was benched for good and Pashos got hurt and I got to say, Snyder and Sims played okay on the right side together in the 2nd half. I thought Staley for the most part did a solid job on Mario Williams, mostly one on one.
I don't know if it was the Texans just went soft or what but with Alex Smith in there our offense moved the ball and Raye showed he can be a little more creative. I hope this continues.
Defense- They played alright, you can't pin the loss on them at all but for the most part they could not make a play and get off the field when needed. We need that premier or at least very good pass rusher. Justin Smith played his tail off as usual and man was he active. Ahmad Brooks with a sack! I hope Spikes will be back in there next week. I hate the zone defense man, Owen Daniels killed is in zone.
ST's- Pathetic, the way we are juggling guys in and out is really effecting are special teams. Also, Arnaz Battle as PR is just not going to cut it.
Overall: There is some hope as Alex Smith looked good and at least we get to see what he can do (I don't think there is anyway Singletary does not keep him in as starter) for the stretch run and we can decide if we do have to go QB next year. I hope Alex countinues to play well and with him, Vernon Davis, Frank Gore, Michael Crabtree and Josh Morgan, we have something to get excited about on offense.
Bottom line though, we are not a playoff team. I don't see us winning the division, at best I think we go 8-8 and it's not just the offense, our defense is not all that great either, it is solid but not as good/great as we need it to be.
There is some hope though, Alex Smith if he plays well would be huge, Vernon Davis and Crabtree, 2 1st rd picks (one should easily be a top 10) now the question is do we have the right HC and OC? Again I have been a big Singletary fan since day one, but man I was dissapointed how sloppy, unorganized and really unprepared this team came out today coming out of a BYE WEEK!!!
Excellent analysis. A very good read.
I think Singletary has to face reality; this isn't a power running team because he says it is and has a tough camp that make his players more physical. This team cannot impose its will on any opponent with the current personnel at the LOS. This has become even more so now that the Niners have played a number of games and teams have film about their limitations.
Singletary's personal philosophy is going to conflict with 49er capabilities and unless he truly and totally surrenders control of the offense to Raye and Smith, you'll see the same predictable boring play-calling. If Singletary didn't want a passing team then he should kept more linemen and RBs instead of 7 WRs. Crabtree, Bruce, Jones, Morgan, and Davis can be formidable with decent QB play. Smith is much more mobile than Hill which makes him a little more effective with our current OL because he can attack the deep middle of the field when he buys a couple extra seconds with his feet.
The question is will Singletary submit? I think the team could have been prepared but are we seeing verification of what coordinators who interviewed here indicated? Can Singletary, regardless of opposition, be telling his coaches what he wants without understanding the limitation of his personnel? I'm starting to wonder if that's the case. I recall him telling Martz "I want to run the ball" - well that's nice, but how? Is it effective?
Singletary has to ask himself if he wants to win or if he want to win using a particular philosophy. The latter will require a couple of off-seasons.
Thank you. I think Singletary's biggest mistake(s) thus far, have been firing Martz and hiring Jimmy Raye as OC. That being said, lets see what Raye can now put together now that he has a QB who can actually throw the ball down the field.