There are 171 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

ALEX SMITH vs. AARON ROGERS STATS COMPARISON (1 HALF vs 1 GAME)

Originally posted by crzy:
We need to let this go.

Of course we should have drafted Rodgers, but it's done. It's four years later. Time to let it go.

f**k aaron rodgers. alex is just fine, as many of us have said this entire time, rodgers and smiths NFL careers are products of their environment. Smith still has the better physical tools and our team is getting better, expect a huge spike in smiths performance. we have good WR's, TE's and a good RB. if our line gives him time and they continue to open up the playbook like they did today smith will be just fine. With smith and Davis we have two young QB's who have a lot of skills to bring to the table, and Hill is a good back up. if smiths progression continues we may not even have to draft a QB, that would be huge for us since we could solidify the O-Line
Originally posted by darkknight49:
Originally posted by luis1985:
Originally posted by boast:

Dude that is freaky.

Perfect for halloween.

Scarier than that STUPID "Paranormal Activity" bulls**t movie!
[ Edited by Buonaparte69 on Oct 25, 2009 at 2:35 PM ]
Originally posted by luis1985:
Originally posted by boast:

Dude that is freaky.

Dude you DO know that it's someone layin on their back with eyes fixed to their chin right?

Not that freaky now is it.

So... Wutt I miss?

~Ceadder
Originally posted by Buonaparte69:
Alex Smith :

15/22 (68.2%) Comp, 206 Yds, 3 TDs, 1 INT, 118.56 QB Rtg (2 rush / 16 Yds)

Aaron Rogers:

15/20 (75.0%) Comp, 246 Yds, 3 TDs, 0 INT, 155.41 QB Rtg

RODGERS NEVER HAD TO FORCE ANY PASSES LIKE SMITH DID....

AND...

we will see when we play GB
Ahhhhh that's right Smith.

Came in sooner than I expected.

But if someone wants to rip him, they gotta give him credit for doing what he did without ONCE working with the 1st team unit.

Not tryin to start nothin at all. But it was about time that Hill was benched. 24-21, We should have won this game. Would have if Sing hadn't kept Hill on the field going in. It is what it is.

We're still up in the Division, but we can't stay comfortable and sticking to "what works" when in fact it hasn't right from the beginning of the season.

~Ceadder
Originally posted by Buonaparte69:
Who was that dude on the webzone who said he had a dream where he saw Alex Smith starting against the Packers (and it was billed as the "showdown between the 2005 Draft QBs")?

Premonition might come true...

PTulini
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Originally posted by Buonaparte69:
Who was that dude on the webzone who said he had a dream where he saw Alex Smith starting against the Packers (and it was billed as the "showdown between the 2005 Draft QBs")?

Premonition might come true...

PTulini

That would be awesome.
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
Originally posted by crzy:
We need to let this go.

Of course we should have drafted Rodgers, but it's done. It's four years later. Time to let it go.

f**k aaron rodgers. alex is just fine, as many of us have said this entire time, rodgers and smiths NFL careers are products of their environment. Smith still has the better physical tools and our team is getting better, expect a huge spike in smiths performance. we have good WR's, TE's and a good RB. if our line gives him time and they continue to open up the playbook like they did today smith will be just fine. With smith and Davis we have two young QB's who have a lot of skills to bring to the table, and Hill is a good back up. if smiths progression continues we may not even have to draft a QB, that would be huge for us since we could solidify the O-Line

All true. That would be awesome if we could worry about something else besides QB in the draft. OL, pass rusher, CB maybe....
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
Originally posted by crzy:
We need to let this go.

Of course we should have drafted Rodgers, but it's done. It's four years later. Time to let it go.

f**k aaron rodgers. alex is just fine, as many of us have said this entire time, rodgers and smiths NFL careers are products of their environment. Smith still has the better physical tools and our team is getting better, expect a huge spike in smiths performance. we have good WR's, TE's and a good RB. if our line gives him time and they continue to open up the playbook like they did today smith will be just fine. With smith and Davis we have two young QB's who have a lot of skills to bring to the table, and Hill is a good back up. if smiths progression continues we may not even have to draft a QB, that would be huge for us since we could solidify the O-Line

All true. That would be awesome if we could worry about something else besides QB in the draft. OL, pass rusher, CB maybe....

Eric Berry then OL, then pass rusher.
Best half of his career and he still can't catch a break.
Originally posted by Buonaparte69:
Who was that dude on the webzone who said he had a dream where he saw Alex Smith starting against the Packers (and it was billed as the "showdown between the 2005 Draft QBs")?

Premonition might come true...

that was patrick tulini, ptulini...Good memory!! haha...
Originally posted by Buonaparte69:
Originally posted by crzy:
We need to let this go.

Of course we should have drafted Rodgers, but it's done. It's four years later. Time to let it go.

NOT the point of this thread!

What is the point. Would anyone hear not trade smith for Rogers?
please dont compare these two
Originally posted by B650:
Hill only had one and a half bad games though.

True,but he wasn't getting it done regardless.


His numbers this year are pedestrian and the offense as a whole sucked with him behind center.