Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
Originally posted by pd24:
Originally posted by BETTERDAYZ9ERS:
32 career games Smith has 31 ints and 19 TD's
18 career games Hill has 23TD's and 11 ints.
I suppose people here know more than Singletary. You guys should call Jed York and ask him to let you pick our personel and decide who should start. Don't forget to let him know about Alex's potential and upside.
Alex was like 21 in his 1st year starting, Hill is 29 and has been watching for like 6 years.
don't give me this smith is young crap he sucks and that's it there are a lot of very young QB's that are very good Ryan,Flacco,Sanchez etc. and these guys didn't sit they started their 1st games as rookies
Well said, but then, I'm sure we'll have an excuse for Alex...after all, he's the #1 overall pick so he has to be special! How could he be #1 if he wasn't special.
Please, we've seen enough. Neither Hill nor Smith are great, but I know that Hill has heart, and that's always worth a lot.
I'm sure after this season is over, we'll be looking for a long term QB, but based on what we have on our current roster, Hill is the right choice.