Originally posted by ninerfan4life:Originally posted by pd24:Originally posted by BETTERDAYZ9ERS:
32 career games Smith has 31 ints and 19 TD's
18 career games Hill has 23TD's and 11 ints.
I suppose people here know more than Singletary. You guys should call Jed York and ask him to let you pick our personel and decide who should start. Don't forget to let him know about Alex's potential and upside.
Alex was like 21 in his 1st year starting, Hill is 29 and has been watching for like 6 years.
don't give me this smith is young crap he sucks and that's it there are a lot of very young QB's that are very good Ryan,Flacco,Sanchez etc. and these guys didn't sit they started their 1st games as rookies
Don't tell me that you are going to try to say that the Niners team Smith started with has the talent that the Falcons/Ravens/Jets have. I have been a Niner fan for over 30 years now and that team was the absolute worst team that I have ever seen them field. I suppose you think that any of the rosters that Smith has played on were as good as any of those rosters, no you are just another one of the guys here that cannot see, or refuse to admit how bad the team was around Smith. That lack of reasoning pretty much ruins your comparison. You put any of those guys on the 2005 Niner team and they end up with the same results. He hasn't played on a team as good as this team is now, we have better talent across the board, other than offensive line, which I call a wash. Just keep on hating Smith for no real reason, blame him for the terrible situation that he was put in, and keep making excuses for a guy that can't even learn to throw a spiral in 9 years, checks down to backs with open receivers downfield on third and long, throws into double and triple coverage, lacks pocket presence, takes unnecessary sacks instead of throwing the ball away. Reasons that when people tried to apply to Smith, were ridiculed as making excuses. Hypocrisy runs rampant on these boards, when reason should win out among intelligent men. I am not in favor of benching Hill at this point, but you guys need to realize that all this hypocrisy makes you all look ignorant. He is what he has always been, a pretty good back up that we are lucky to have, but nowhere near a top tier NFL QB.