Originally posted by blunt_probe:
Originally posted by taney71:
What exactly is he going to do if given time? He plays at best on the same level as Hill.
Great logic. Why even have Alex Smith on the team if there are so many haters?
They play on the same level???
Hill-dinks and dunks, can't throw down field, can't throw a spiral, Receivers have been heard comparing Hill's passes to "coming down like a punt", can hand the ball off
Smith-spreads the ball, inconsistant, happy feet, can get the ball down field, can throw a tight spiral, can throw the dink and dunks that Hill does, can hand the ball off.
If you ask me they are close to the same level. Both QB will manage a game when winning or the game is close. but in a blow out like today Smith clearly gives you the best chance to get some points.