Are you happy with Hill's Performance?

Did he overthrow guys? Yes
Did he throw at the floor one too many times? Yes
Did the o-line give him great protection? No
Did receivers drop passes? I don't remember

and that is the truth!

I didn't like his performance, but I blame the loss on our defense.

Originally posted by teeohh:
Did he overthrow guys? Yes
Did he throw at the floor one too many times? Yes
Did the o-line give him great protection? No
Did receivers drop passes? I don't remember

and that is the truth!

I didn't like his performance, but I blame the loss on our defense.

,

So Hill can only win if the D plays lights out

Originally posted by teeohh:
Did he overthrow guys? Yes
Did he throw at the floor one too many times? Yes
Did the o-line give him great protection? No
Did receivers drop passes? I don't remember

and that is the truth!

I didn't like his performance, but I blame the loss on our defense.

Our defense was a problem, but a pethetic O is a great defenses worst friend.

Originally posted by teeohh:
Did he overthrow guys? Yes
Did he throw at the floor one too many times? Yes
Did the o-line give him great protection? No
Did receivers drop passes? I don't remember

and that is the truth!

I didn't like his performance, but I blame the loss on our defense.

Dude, just like last week was a team win in every phase of the game (Defense, Offense, Special teams), this was a team loss from start to finish.

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Not happy with Hill's performance today, but still not off his bandwagon. How many times did he turn the ball over today....once, and that was by a tipped pass. How many TD's did the defense give up today....too many to count. I'm not saying Hill doesn't deserve blame, but its not all on him.

Regular 3 and outs are only slightly better then turnovers.

Originally posted by Cuphalffull:

Originally posted by teeohh:
Did he overthrow guys? Yes
Did he throw at the floor one too many times? Yes
Did the o-line give him great protection? No
Did receivers drop passes? I don't remember

and that is the truth!

I didn't like his performance, but I blame the loss on our defense.

Our defense was a problem, but a pethetic O is a great defenses worst friend.

ding ding ding

Shaun Hill was bad enough tonight for me to ponder

1 - Playing Alex in the second half
2 - The signing of Jeff Garcia for the rest of the year.
3 - When will Nate be ready
4 - Colt McCoy/Jevan Snead/Sam Bradford/Clausen/Locker etc etc etc

Originally posted by BrianUKNiner:
Shaun Hill was bad enough tonight for me to ponder

1 - Playing Alex in the second half
2 - The signing of Jeff Garcia for the rest of the year.
3 - When will Nate be ready
4 - Colt McCoy/Jevan Snead/Sam Bradford/Clausen/Locker etc etc etc

Jevan Snead looked horrible against Alabama (which is the best team team in college football right now) yesterday. I live in SEC country and have seen most of his games and Snead has really not been impressive at all this year. Decision making is very questionable. I would not be surprised to see him slip on the draft boards.

My favorite part about watching Hill is seeing him try to throw a fade/Go route on the sidleine. Its hilarious, i literally rewind it and laugh everytime i see it. Its a DUCK in the air, cruises up end over end, comes down after the receiver and cornerback have to wait on it, and more like 80% of the time its out of bounds.

MONEY PLAY

No, but he's the best we have....

Shaun was brought in to manage the game, and I think he continues to do it as per expectation. He is the best QB we have in our "current" roster. Alex had his chances...again...and again, and turns out he is NOT upto it. Just 'cause we lost 45-10, doesn't mean Alex is automatically better.
As for Nate, pre-season is diff than regular season. Just ask Coffee!

We had a meltdown on defense. The reason we won the games so far, was mostly 'cause of our defense. We go as far as our defense takes us. That's just our philosophy for this year.
Hill made one mistake...well, it was a tip or something, so he is not the "main" reason we lost. Our OLINE and defense needs to step up big time, otherwise, no matter who the QB, is bound to get hurt.
Oh, we don't have any WRs either!

We have to take a step back, analyze what went wrong and make the tweak. Maybe, we after all are just an avg team? No Gore? OLINE is our weakest link? all the hype got to us? the Crabtree distraction? overconfidence? who knows.
Silver lining: we have two weeks to get better. Gore and Crabtree can hopefully contribute.

not on 10/11/09.

Originally posted by 49ersking:
Shaun was brought in to manage the game, and I think he continues to do it as per expectation. He is the best QB we have in our "current" roster. Alex had his chances...again...and again, and turns out he is NOT upto it. Just 'cause we lost 45-10, doesn't mean Alex is automatically better.
As for Nate, pre-season is diff than regular season. Just ask Coffee!

We had a meltdown on defense. The reason we won the games so far, was mostly 'cause of our defense. We go as far as our defense takes us. That's just our philosophy for this year.
Hill made one mistake...well, it was a tip or something, so he is not the "main" reason we lost. Our OLINE and defense needs to step up big time, otherwise, no matter who the QB, is bound to get hurt.
Oh, we don't have any WRs either!

We have to take a step back, analyze what went wrong and make the tweak. Maybe, we after all are just an avg team? No Gore? OLINE is our weakest link? all the hype got to us? the Crabtree distraction? overconfidence? who knows.
Silver lining: we have two weeks to get better. Gore and Crabtree can hopefully contribute.

I don't get it. Alex had a pretty good second season and the Niners were 2-1 when he got injured. Yet, somehow, he has blown chances "over and over" again.

Originally posted by 49ersking:
Shaun was brought in to manage the game, and I think he continues to do it as per expectation. He is the best QB we have in our "current" roster. Alex had his chances...again...and again, and turns out he is NOT upto it. Just 'cause we lost 45-10, doesn't mean Alex is automatically better.
As for Nate, pre-season is diff than regular season. Just ask Coffee!

We had a meltdown on defense. The reason we won the games so far, was mostly 'cause of our defense. We go as far as our defense takes us. That's just our philosophy for this year.
Hill made one mistake...well, it was a tip or something, so he is not the "main" reason we lost. Our OLINE and defense needs to step up big time, otherwise, no matter who the QB, is bound to get hurt.
Oh, we don't have any WRs either!

We have to take a step back, analyze what went wrong and make the tweak. Maybe, we after all are just an avg team? No Gore? OLINE is our weakest link? all the hype got to us? the Crabtree distraction? overconfidence? who knows.
Silver lining: we have two weeks to get better. Gore and Crabtree can hopefully contribute.

Alex did not have his chances again and again. Love this revisionist history by Smith haters. Just stop it.

Originally posted by taney71:

Originally posted by 49ersking:
Shaun was brought in to manage the game, and I think he continues to do it as per expectation. He is the best QB we have in our "current" roster. Alex had his chances...again...and again, and turns out he is NOT upto it. Just 'cause we lost 45-10, doesn't mean Alex is automatically better.
As for Nate, pre-season is diff than regular season. Just ask Coffee!

We had a meltdown on defense. The reason we won the games so far, was mostly 'cause of our defense. We go as far as our defense takes us. That's just our philosophy for this year.
Hill made one mistake...well, it was a tip or something, so he is not the "main" reason we lost. Our OLINE and defense needs to step up big time, otherwise, no matter who the QB, is bound to get hurt.
Oh, we don't have any WRs either!

We have to take a step back, analyze what went wrong and make the tweak. Maybe, we after all are just an avg team? No Gore? OLINE is our weakest link? all the hype got to us? the Crabtree distraction? overconfidence? who knows.
Silver lining: we have two weeks to get better. Gore and Crabtree can hopefully contribute.

Alex did not have his chances again and again. Love this revisionist history by Smith haters. Just stop it.

Not a Smith hater...rather a 49ers fan! Smith also had his chance in the off-season and he was passed over for Hill. The coaches felt Hill was better, Singletary felt Hill was better.
Granted we don't have Peyton Manning in Hill, but he's the best we've got in the current roster.