There are 78 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Players we MUST retain!

Originally posted by backontop:
Why do we have to resign Brown and Goldson? What have they done yet?

Goldson has played fine so far, if hes not making mistakes and getting burnt then I'm fine keeping him.
Originally posted by backontop:
Why do we have to resign Brown and Goldson? What have they done yet?

when clements was injured last year vs the jets, brown did a spectacular job IMO. i think he's gunna be good
Originally posted by SFL49ER:
Originally posted by backontop:
Why do we have to resign Brown and Goldson? What have they done yet?

Goldson, are you serious? He IS our fastest man on defense. The man is one of the best in the league, watch. He is a freaking baller who has great instincts and speed and run support and makes great hits; he hits hard and clean, and also tackles with real good technique. He has good agility and ball skills too. His next int might go to the house because of his speed. (Dont know yet if he can break tackles.) Our best DB in production at the end of the year is my prediction.

On one play when there was a run up the middle for little to no gain in game 3, the guy who busted in there to make sure the RB went down was Goldson. The DLine stopped the run with holding their ground but instead of a LB cleaning up the play, Goldson came crashing in like a freight train. If you rewatch the game and look for the play, you'll see it, believe meeee!

Dude,

How do you go from oft injured, never starting, to one of the best in the league in 3 games?

I too like what I have seen SO FAR, but I am not ready put him in that class. One day maybe, but not yet.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
You guys overrate Nate Davis big time. He is the most overrated player on the WZ. He is as overrated in Niner Talk as Megan Fox is in the Parking Lot.


lol didn't you just say that about Battle?

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
What the hell has Battle proven? That he has banged up knees, is slow and is an under performer. I'd much rather start Jason Hill over him. Battle is the most overrated guy on the 49ersWebzone. A #5 WR at best on most teams. He just played here for a number of years because we had garbage. Josh Morgan and Jason Hill are both better than him.

-9fA
[ Edited by 9erfanAUS on Sep 30, 2009 at 1:22 PM ]
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Originally posted by SFL49ER:
Originally posted by backontop:
Why do we have to resign Brown and Goldson? What have they done yet?

Goldson, are you serious? He IS our fastest man on defense. The man is one of the best in the league, watch. He is a freaking baller who has great instincts and speed and run support and makes great hits; he hits hard and clean, and also tackles with real good technique. He has good agility and ball skills too. His next int might go to the house because of his speed. (Dont know yet if he can break tackles.) Our best DB in production at the end of the year is my prediction.

On one play when there was a run up the middle for little to no gain in game 3, the guy who busted in there to make sure the RB went down was Goldson. The DLine stopped the run with holding their ground but instead of a LB cleaning up the play, Goldson came crashing in like a freight train. If you rewatch the game and look for the play, you'll see it, believe meeee!

Dude,

How do you go from oft injured, never starting, to one of the best in the league in 3 games?

I too like what I have seen SO FAR, but I am not ready put him in that class. One day maybe, but not yet.

That is exactly my point. Nobody has seen enough of either one of them to say we MUST retain these guys. I am not saying that we shouldn't but I will reserve my opinion for a later date when I have seen enough of these two to actually make an opinion on them.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
You guys overrate Nate Davis big time. He is the most overrated player on the WZ. He is as overrated in Niner Talk as Megan Fox is in the Parking Lot.


Mark Sanchez looked good in the preseason, and then looked good in the regular season just the same.

There is a reason to be exited about Nate Davis.

Nobody has written down in blood in a holy book that he is a great player, it is just excitement about what he has shown.

Can fans at least be exited about players who have potential?

Can we at least have that?

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
You guys overrate Nate Davis big time. He is the most overrated player on the WZ. He is as overrated in Niner Talk as Megan Fox is in the Parking Lot.


the most overrated player is Kory Sheets not Nate Davis
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by teeohh:
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by SFL49ER:
Originally posted by backontop:
Why do we have to resign Brown and Goldson? What have they done yet?

Goldson, are you serious? He IS our fastest man on defense. The man is one of the best in the league, watch. He is a freaking baller who has great instincts and speed and run support and makes great hits; he hits hard and clean, and also tackles with real good technique. He has good agility and ball skills too. His next int might go to the house because of his speed. (Dont know yet if he can break tackles.) Our best DB in production at the end of the year is my prediction.

On one play when there was a run up the middle for little to no gain in game 3, the guy who busted in there to make sure the RB went down was Goldson. The DLine stopped the run with holding their ground but instead of a LB cleaning up the play, Goldson came crashing in like a freight train. If you rewatch the game and look for the play, you'll see it, believe meeee!


Thats fine and dandy but to say we need to resign him now based on 2-3 games of performance is insane. At least wait the rest of the season and see how he produces. All I am saying is be patient. The team always extens contracts on players and then they turn out to be garbage. I wonder why that is. Example: anyone remember a guy by the name of Ahmed Plummer? I rest my case

Brown may have won the starting spot if he hadn't gotten injured. They see him as someone worth keeping that could develop into a starter, that's all that matters right now. Its good that we resign guys while they're cheap and before they have a chance to hit the market. I think it's smart if you ask me. And I doubt he will receive a huge contract so relax.

Just because he "COULD" be a starter doesn't mean we need to extend his contract or resign him right away. Let the guy hit the field and prove that he deserves to resigned.

The problem is, if you wait until they are proven, the price of the player shoots way up to the stars.

If you sign players you think are good, but are unproven (Staley, Spencer, Haralson) then you can get them at a discount.

If you only ever sign players who are absolutely proven, you will get killed by the salary cap and you will never have enough talent to win.

You don't sign players early because you think you're so clever that you don't need to wait, you sign them early because the modern NFL is all about the salary cap.
Meh too soon, besides the obvious players
Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
You guys overrate Nate Davis big time. He is the most overrated player on the WZ. He is as overrated in Niner Talk as Megan Fox is in the Parking Lot.


lol didn't you just say that about Battle?

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
What the hell has Battle proven? That he has banged up knees, is slow and is an under performer. I'd much rather start Jason Hill over him. Battle is the most overrated guy on the 49ersWebzone. A #5 WR at best on most teams. He just played here for a number of years because we had garbage. Josh Morgan and Jason Hill are both better than him.

-9fA

Originally posted by valrod33:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
You guys overrate Nate Davis big time. He is the most overrated player on the WZ. He is as overrated in Niner Talk as Megan Fox is in the Parking Lot.


the most overrated player is Kory Sheets not Nate Davis

50/50
Originally posted by BrianGO:
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by teeohh:
Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by SFL49ER:
Originally posted by backontop:
Why do we have to resign Brown and Goldson? What have they done yet?

Goldson, are you serious? He IS our fastest man on defense. The man is one of the best in the league, watch. He is a freaking baller who has great instincts and speed and run support and makes great hits; he hits hard and clean, and also tackles with real good technique. He has good agility and ball skills too. His next int might go to the house because of his speed. (Dont know yet if he can break tackles.) Our best DB in production at the end of the year is my prediction.

On one play when there was a run up the middle for little to no gain in game 3, the guy who busted in there to make sure the RB went down was Goldson. The DLine stopped the run with holding their ground but instead of a LB cleaning up the play, Goldson came crashing in like a freight train. If you rewatch the game and look for the play, you'll see it, believe meeee!


Thats fine and dandy but to say we need to resign him now based on 2-3 games of performance is insane. At least wait the rest of the season and see how he produces. All I am saying is be patient. The team always extens contracts on players and then they turn out to be garbage. I wonder why that is. Example: anyone remember a guy by the name of Ahmed Plummer? I rest my case

Brown may have won the starting spot if he hadn't gotten injured. They see him as someone worth keeping that could develop into a starter, that's all that matters right now. Its good that we resign guys while they're cheap and before they have a chance to hit the market. I think it's smart if you ask me. And I doubt he will receive a huge contract so relax.

Just because he "COULD" be a starter doesn't mean we need to extend his contract or resign him right away. Let the guy hit the field and prove that he deserves to resigned.

The problem is, if you wait until they are proven, the price of the player shoots way up to the stars.

If you sign players you think are good, but are unproven (Staley, Spencer, Haralson) then you can get them at a discount.

If you only ever sign players who are absolutely proven, you will get killed by the salary cap and you will never have enough talent to win.

You don't sign players early because you think you're so clever that you don't need to wait, you sign them early because the modern NFL is all about the salary cap.

Staley, Spencer and Harolson have all proved they were worth the extention through their play on the field. Brown and Goldson have played a few games. Again all I am saying is don't get ahead of yourselves here. Let the season play out before you start calling for a contract extention. For all you know Brown and Goldson could end up completely sucking the rest of the season. I am not saying it will happen but nobody knows what will happen during the season yet.
We could start by signing our top draft pick...
Originally posted by King49er:
We could start by signing our top draft pick...

not at the the price he wants only the slotted price
  • Chico
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,204
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
Originally posted by King49er:
We could start by signing our top draft pick...

not at the the price he wants only the slotted price

I PRAY that we CUT CRABBIE PATTIE!!!

Get rid of him and bring in Sponge Bob! Attitude produces 100 times more than negativeness!
...