Originally posted by CoffeeMachine:Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Did you not see that game last night? Smith played better than Hill, yet you want to dump Smith and make Hill the starter? Huard is not better than either Hill or Smith or the coaches would have him starting...good thing people that know football are making the calls.
Smith played better than Hill? All Smith did was stall the offense. Maybe we watched different games but I saw him play against the Raiders last night.
Smith did play better than Hill, Hill looked lost when the raiders were jumping the underneath routes, just like last years game against the Rams when Hill threw three picks. Smith made his reads correctly and delivered the ball to the receivers. It is not on Smith that the receivers dropped those passes, they hit them all in the hands. Smith didn't stall drives, receivers dropping very catchable passes stalled drives. Hill didn't do any better than Smith, Coffee was the one sustaining those drives. I am not saying Smith was great, he only showed a little improvement, I am just saying Hill played worse, and was outperformed, which is did not expect at all. Regardless of which, both need to step it up if we are going to have a decent season.