Originally posted by valrod33:Originally posted by ApatheticIAm:Originally posted by valrod33:Originally posted by ApatheticIAm:Originally posted by valrod33:Originally posted by ApatheticIAm:Originally posted by valrod33:Originally posted by ApatheticIAm:
If we lose to Seattle, I think it would be the biggest letdown/disappointment in Alex Smith's career. Yea we had faith and confidence before, but he never looked this good or confident. Now it's like we know what he can do, so he just has to do it. Before we were on that "potential" and "upside" pipe dream.
I hate to say it, if Alex Smith loses this game, especially because of interceptions and fumbles, I think his career is over (at least as a starter). You may think i'm rash because of how good he played last week, but he set himself up for this. Win and he's our QB no doubt. Win against AZ then no more searching. Lose this game and beat AZ next week then we will all shun him and never trust him because of his inconsistency.
i like how you blame Alex already and the game hasnt even been played yet
what if the niners lose because of a fumble by frank gore or a special teams f**k up, assuming that if the niners lose its already Alex Smiths fault is just plain stupid
Wow did you read what I said?
I said IF HE fumbles and throws interceptions, not because of the receiver running a bad route but because he made a bad read.
Obviously if Gore fumbles then the game is not on him. If he has one of those meltdown games like Tennessee, maybe I should have said I won't trust him anymore.
At what point was I already blaming him for the loss? It was a bunch of speculation. I think most fans will have this feeling IF IF IF it happens. I am the biggest AS supporter, just check my resume (if you can). I want nothing but the best for him. I hope he lights it up on Sunday.
But what if he throws 3 or 4 interceptions and consensus shows the loss was on him? How will YOU feel?
Did you read what you said? Your First paragraph
If we lose to Seattle, I think it would be the biggest letdown/disappointment in Alex Smith's career
you then say
I hate to say it, if Alex Smith loses this game, especially because of interceptions and fumbles, I think his career is over (at least as a starter).
to me this implies that if Alex loses the game you dont have faith in him and if its cuz of turnovers then his career is over
Exactly. If he loses this game because he makes bone head decisions then I will have no more faith in him. If he loses, to me it means he can't win big games. Plain and simple.
well thats just stupid
Why you gotta call me and Joecool stupid?? huh huh
But seriously we've been through this before with Alex, except on a smaller scale. Now it's time for him to step it up, or leave.
But it doesn't matter because most of the zone is hell bent that Alex will be the starter next year no matter what. He probably will with the signs hes shown thus far.
In the end, Go Alex!!! more importantly go Niners!!!
go Alex go
one quick note, I agree this is a big game for him, but if he fails(he wont) but if he does can we really say he isnt a big game player because what other big games has he had so far in his career, its not like we have been a playoff contender
He's played big before. People forget he had some good drives during his second year and I believe in his first or second game during his 3rd year in the league before he got hurt. Were they big games? No. But this team hasn't been good enough during the last 6 or 7 years to play in any.