As much as I like Davis, you guys are pretty much spot on. Yes, a top-10 pick must make plays. He's got to be a perennial pro-bowler to merit that high draft pick. I just think that in the right system and given the right coaching, Vernon Davis can get there.
I know I sound like a broken record, but I still can't get over that very first game. When he grabbed that little crossing route and beat the entire Cards secondary to the endzone, I fell out of my chair and said "we've got a winner!" Obviously, I've been disappointed but Jimmy Raye gives me hope.