We wouldve easily won it all in 2012 (imagine Manning-Brady bowl for the championship), obviously won in 2013, and couldve beat the Hawks in 2014 in the NFCC. Potential for 3-peat and even if Manning wins 2 of those 3, he goes down easily as the GOAT.
Instead, he bites on Elway's offer (maybe he didnt want to compete with baby brother in the NFC) and he will leave the game playing second fiddle to Brady, not to mention join the ranks of great regular season QBs that choked in the playoffs.
Sometimes you have to be greedy as a player, and Peyton made the ultimate legacy killer move by not joining Harbs when he had the chance.
Thoughts ?
[ Edited by KP82 on Nov 15, 2015 at 3:55 PM ]