Everything should be up for review and I like the idea of centralized review system. Asking the ref who made the questionable call in the first place to go under the hood is stupid. He'll be less inclined to over-turn his call unless it's 110% obvious that he was wrong. Even in such cases - refs have f**ked up.
Yes, all turnovers are reviewed...but IMO - all plays that could have resulted in a TO should be reviewed as well. So, if someone fumbled the ball but refs called him down by contact - it should be reviewed automatically OR don't f**king call down by contract and let it be a TO so you can go back and review it - use common f**king sense. Fumbles and interceptions are big plays and can change the game completely.
...also - I don't know what the f**k is a catch anymore. Keep it simple and clear for viewers as well as refs. Also...running QBs should get the same protection as pocket-passers if they're in the pocket. You shouldn't be judged differently because you have an ability to run fast.
I'm all for protecting players. Current rules are fine and it's not pussification of the game. The doodes are bigger and faster...f = m x a. Therefore, NFL needs to protect these guys.
[ Edited by 4ML on Feb 6, 2014 at 8:15 PM ]