There are 118 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

What if Peyton Manning had signed with the Niners?

Originally posted by Janitor:
Manning gets injured in week 4 because he can't run out of the pocket when it collapses. Since Alex went to the Dolphins and Kap was traded to the Eagles for Vick and a 2014 pick, Vick takes over and leads us to a 6-10 season. Yay.

Meantime the Eagles are starting their Quest for Two.
Originally posted by English:
Originally posted by Janitor:
Manning gets injured in week 4 because he can't run out of the pocket when it collapses. Since Alex went to the Dolphins and Kap was traded to the Eagles for Vick and a 2014 pick, Vick takes over and leads us to a 6-10 season. Yay.

Meantime the Eagles are starting their Quest for Two.

2012 Pete Carroll is fired after another 7-9 season and starting QB Tavares Jackson is released and signed by San Francisco after Manning officially retires. Michael Crabtree requests to be traded.

meanwhile, defending nfc west division champs, St. Louis Rams are looking over their shoulder as the develoment of arizona cardinals QB Russell Wilson continues to impress.
Don't forget after they would have paid Mannings $20 million a year the team would not have been the same.
well, he does have 4 elite play makers in denver. but i do think he would've won us the game against the seahawks. we really needed better passing when it counted. overall though, i would rather have Kaep. he can be our franchise QB for another 10 years, while Manning probably has a good 2-3 year left in the tank.
Back to Back Super Bowl Wins and he retires ala Elway style before grooming Kap for over 2 years. Kap wins our next Super Bowl at our home turf in Santa Clara SuperBowl 50.

Woulda been a 3 peat.
Originally posted by Eli_23:
Back to Back Super Bowl Wins and he retires ala Elway style before grooming Kap for over 2 years. Kap wins our next Super Bowl at our home turf in Santa Clara SuperBowl 50.

Woulda been a 3 peat.

pretty darn accurate.
We would have to expand the trophy case.
He'd be out of the league by now. Our line couldn't protect him. IMO.
we would be working on number 7
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:
He'd be out of the league by now. Our line couldn't protect him. IMO.

The 49ers have a better O Line than Denver has. He just makes them look better because he reads the field so well, gets the ball out quick and is accurate. A moderate O Line is fine for Manning because he is so good.
All of 49ers fans called him too old.. Its really embarrsing now they wanted hin our 49ers team?. Ure too late that we cant have him our team anymore. Sadly... Ur fault of all 49ers fans..
Originally posted by eonblue:
He doesnt throw 2 picks in the 4th Qtr of the NFCCG.
But he does throw picks in the Overtime of the divisional round game
If I could change the past and have P. Manning sign with us Id say NO!
Manning gets career-ending injury after the Divisional game (Carolina would kill Peyton), we go into the Championship with Colt McCoy or Tolzien.
Welp, guess the the whole Manning discussion can finally end.