There are 84 users in the forums

GOAT: Peyton Manning vs Joe Montana comparison threads

Well when Payton hits you you get a lump. When joe hits you you get four.
Manning is amazing.

But would rank terry Bradshaw in this convo? He has 4 rings too.

Is it all about rings? Or stats?

Who would you want with the game on the line?

You got to go with joe cool
Montana, based on post season greatness and clutch ability
Brady, stats and post season greatness but it's clear he's not on joes level in the post season
Manning - elite ref season QB but major choke artist
Share 49erswebzone