Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Hall got wide open for a TD against the chiefs but Kap badly overthrew him, not his fault.
Collie has a terrible history of injuries, I fear for his safety and he doesn't offer any ST contributions.
I think you're blowing it way out of proportion, step off the hype train. Collie hasn't had a concussion since 2010, last year he had a freakish knee injury, similar to what happened to Crabtree, can't really blame him for that, s**t just happens. What's undeniable is that he's been incredibly productive in the NFL and at the same age as Hall, has roughly about 2000 yards more receiving, not to mention playoff and Superbowl experience.
i think he's a more talented and polished wr than hall, i'm just worried another big hit and he's done. his history of injuries is just a fact.
hall would be a option route/slot wr and can contribute on ST which collie cannot, also would probably be cheaper.