Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
My comparison to KW is based on similar movement...speedy and shifty, and will be used in a similar fashion. It is also based on the fact that, for all intents and purposes, Patton will be taking the roster spot KW has vacated...behind Crabtree, Boldin and Manningham. He will likely be the fourth WR if activated...but he might not be as they tend to use one spot for STs.
And Jones--when did Wayne play for the niners? Try using a bit of imagination before responding.
But...they're really nothing alike. You can't just compare one guy to another because he formerly occupied a roster spot on the team. Patton can play in the slot, he can also play on the outside, Williams is a slot guy who wasn't a very good route runner, built smaller, a different type of receiver, more a deep threat than Patton but not as complete of a receiver. The Reggie Wayne comparison is a good one in terms of how Patton looked in college, now I can only hope that he gets a chance to show it out on the field and make plays for this team.
Actually you can! We compare Gore to Hunter to James with the greatest of ease...why? Because they play the same position. My point is that Patton is a better version of a crafty, quick receiver. He's not 6'4" nor is he a 4.2 40 guy...they are both similar in that regard and I believe Patton will play a very similar role...although KW was used very seldom...or he was able to be effective seldom.
But...if you try to compare Patton to Boldin, Crabtree or KW it seems fairly obvious he is most like KW in his smooth stride and medium size. Both Boldin and Crabtree are bigger than Patton. As far as the rest is concerned, he will have to demonstrate he is actually better than KW and he hasn't had the chance to do so yet.
Edit--Patton will be the 3rd receiver at best this year and likely the fourth behind Manningham.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Dec 9, 2013 at 5:35 PM ]