4. Manning (Peyton)
Top 5 are firm, Wilson and Kaep are equal in my eyes at 6. Numbers 8 and 9 are up for grabs. My homer side wants Alex Smith on this list. He's been playing great football, we'll see how he does in KC. I wish him the best. There is also Eli, Big Ben, Stafford, Luck... etc... who am I missing? Possibly Vick? He may just redeem himself next season. Joe Cool currently deserves a spot because the ring, but he won't be there long. Ryan at 9 is controversial due to him having arguably the best WR/TE core in the league, but he's been playing great.
[ Edited by 49Perspectives on Mar 31, 2013 at 1:25 AM ]