Originally posted by DaManRathman:I feel it should go to AP, but I think they will end up giving it to Manning.
I feel it should go to Manning and they'll probably give it to him.
Peterson carried his team to the playoffs, but he doesn't make them a Super Bowl caliber team. They barely snuck into the playoffs and are likely to get bounced in the first round.
Peyton, on the other hand, has made the Broncos a Super Bowl caliber team and are likely favorites to represent the AFC in February. Granted, the Broncos were in the playoffs last year, but they didn't deserve to be. They are where they are because of Peyton Manning.
Peyton is the MVP of a much better team. A team that is only that good because of him. He should win MVP and Comeback Player of the Year.