Who is the 2nd best WR ever?

I know he is hated, but I am going to have to go with...

Originally posted by valrod33:

BALCO

PSHHHHH


TIM BROWN lol


I used to always hear that bs from raider fans back in the day. They were so jealous and delusional about T.B. that they even said he was better than Rice.

Moss all the way.

The only other WR that has put up great/consistent numbers over a long career. Tim Brown.

I have to go with Moss, just from memory I believe T.O. had a higher percentage of drops than he did.

Originally posted by BobS:
I have to go with Moss, just from memory I believe T.O. had a higher percentage of drops than he did.

Same, I'd go with Moss. He's still an A hole.

Josh Morgan

Originally posted by TheG0RE49er:
The only other WR that has put up great/consistent numbers over a long career. Tim Brown.

Year Team G Rec Yds Avg Yds/G Lng TD 20+ 40+ 1st FUM
2010 Cincinnati Bengals 14 72 983 13.7 70.2 78T 9 15 3 47 0

2009 Buffalo Bills 16 55 829 15.1 51.8 98T 5 9 5 33 1

2008 Dallas Cowboys 16 69 1,052 15.2 65.8 75T 10 15 6 38 1

2007 Dallas Cowboys 15 81 1,355 16.7 90.3 52T 15 22 6 69 0

2006 Dallas Cowboys 16 85 1,180 13.9 73.8 56T 13 18 4 62 0

2005 Philadelphia Eagles 7 47 763 16.2 109.0 91T 6 10 4 32 0

2004 Philadelphia Eagles 14 77 1,200 15.6 85.7 59T 14 20 9 51 2

2003 San Francisco 49ers 15 80 1,102 13.8 73.5 75T 9 15 4 55 0

2002 San Francisco 49ers 14 100 1,300 13.0 92.9 76T 13 17 5 61 0

2001 San Francisco 49ers 16 93 1,412 15.2 88.2 60T 16 21 6 70 0

2000 San Francisco 49ers 14 97 1,451 15.0 103.6 69T 13 23 5 65 2

1999 San Francisco 49ers 14 60 754 12.6 53.9 36 4 12 0 36 1

1998 San Francisco 49ers 16 67 1,097 16.4 68.6 79T 14 17 4 52 1

1997 San Francisco 49ers 16 60 936 15.6 58.5 56T 8 16 1 48 1

1996 San Francisco 49ers 16 35 520 14.9 32.5 46T 4 7 2 23 1

TOTAL 219 1,078 15,934 14.8 72.8 98 153 237 64 742 10


Tim Brown

2004 Tampa Bay Buccaneers 15 24 200 8.3 13.3 21 1 1 0 8 2

2003 Oakland Raiders 16 52 567 10.9 35.4 36T 2 8 0 28 0

2002 Oakland Raiders 16 81 930 11.5 58.1 45 2 11 2 48 0

2001 Oakland Raiders 16 91 1,165 12.8 72.8 46T 9 18 2 61 0

2000 Oakland Raiders 16 76 1,128 14.8 70.5 45 11 19 3 59 0

1999 Oakland Raiders 16 90 1,344 14.9 84.0 47 6 18 5 64 0

1998 Oakland Raiders 16 81 1,012 12.5 63.2 49 9 12 1 52 2

1997 Oakland Raiders 16 104 1,408 13.5 88.0 59T 5 20 2 65 1

1996 Oakland Raiders 16 90 1,104 12.3 69.0 42T 9 16 2 58 1

1995 Oakland Raiders 16 89 1,342 15.1 83.9 80T 10 18 4 66 0

1994 Los Angeles Raiders 16 89 1,309 14.7 81.8 77T 9 17 4 68 1

1993 Los Angeles Raiders 16 80 1,180 14.8 73.8 71T 7 15 2 57 0

1992 Los Angeles Raiders 15 49 693 14.1 46.2 68T 7 9 2 33 2

1991 Los Angeles Raiders 16 36 554 15.4 34.6 78T 5 10 2 26 0

1990 Los Angeles Raiders 16 18 265 14.7 16.6 51 3 -- -- -- --

1989 Los Angeles Raiders 1 1 8 8.0 8.0 8 0 -- -- -- --

1988 Los Angeles Raiders 16 43 725 16.9 45.3 65T 5 -- -- -- --

TOTAL 255 1,094 14,934 13.7 58.6 80 100 192 31 693 9

how is tim brown better thann T.O?

Don Hutson

TO is an incredible locker room cancer... But one of the great big game players in any sport, at any position, of all time. Athletic, confident, focused, and driven. Just too much of a chemistry liability.

Moss is up there with LeBron as the greatest physical specimen in sports. But is a lazy looser, and therefore I have a hard time awarding that to him.

But Fitzgerald should be on the list. Imagine if he played his entire career with a Warner (or equivalent), as Rice/Irvin/Moss (somewhat)/TO did. He may be the 2nd best when all is said and done.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Don Hutson

guy wouldnt make a team now days

Originally posted by FreddyG:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Don Hutson

guy wouldnt make a team now days

Whats to say Jerry Rice would make a team in 2085? It is all relative. You have to look at who dominated the game at the time he was playing. That guy dominated.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Don Hutson

yup, this. Dude was the first really great WR, and you have to include him for his significance to the game.

The other WRs in this poll are all pretty great, but they only really represent one era--the era of the WR. Maybe "Hutson wouldn't make a team nowadays" (highly unlikely, even on a purely speculative level; if Don Hutson were born today and conditioned like athletes today are, is it impossible to think that he would make a team?), but he was a dominant player who owned a ton of records that stood for a long time.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by FreddyG:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Don Hutson

guy wouldnt make a team now days

Whats to say Jerry Rice would make a team in 2085? It is all relative. You have to look at who dominated the game at the time he was playing. That guy dominated.

touche...

Originally posted by FreddyG:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Don Hutson

guy wouldnt make a team now days

People say the same thing about Montana.