Aikman better than Young??

Originally posted by pantstickle:
Stats for Troy Aikman and Brad Johnson

2668-4326
61.7%
29,054 yards
166/122 TD/INT
82.5 QB rating

2898-4715
61.5%
32,942
165/141 TD/INT
81.6 QB rating

There's no point in putting a name with the stats, because there's almost no difference! Troy was great from 92-95, but every other season of his was average. Hell, Aikman only had 5 winning seasons as a quarterback. And IWAS, here's where the "great team" shows itself. If a quarterback only excelled because he was on a great team, then his stats will show that, like they do with Aikman. Looking at Montana and Young's stats, they were consistently good every year they played.

Originally posted by pantstickle:
Stats for Troy Aikman and Brad Johnson

2668-4326
61.7%
29,054 yards
166/122 TD/INT
82.5 QB rating

2898-4715
61.5%
32,942
165/141 TD/INT
81.6 QB rating

There's no point in putting a name with the stats, because there's almost no difference! Troy was great from 92-95, but every other season of his was average. Hell, Aikman only had 5 winning seasons as a quarterback. And IWAS, here's where the "great team" shows itself. If a quarterback only excelled because he was on a great team, then his stats will show that, like they do with Aikman. Looking at Montana and Young's stats, they were consistently good every year they played.