There are 89 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

NFL positional player rankings

http://www.jiraentertainment.com/2010/07/jira-entertainment-nfl-player-rankings/


Any feedback is appreciated and im sure I will get some good and bad
Im not clicking on your links anymore after your NBA mock draft
Rodgers is to high
McNabb is to low
Grant is to high
Where is Barber
Avery shouldn't even be on that list
Rice is to high
TE's are good
Swap Long and Thomas
I would put J Allen at the top of the list
J Smith is a lil low for my homerism
Move Mayo and Lewis up
Originally posted by valrod33:
Im not clicking on your links anymore after your NBA mock draft


I admit im not the biggest NBA guy and I did the NBA draft mock just for fun.
Originally posted by jreff22:
Rodgers is to high
McNabb is to low
Grant is to high
Where is Barber
Avery shouldn't even be on that list
Rice is to high
TE's are good
Swap Long and Thomas
I would put J Allen at the top of the list
J Smith is a lil low for my homerism
Move Mayo and Lewis up


Ronde Barber? I think he is pretty much washed up. Appreciate all the feedback though, thanks.
Originally posted by PatrickJira411:
Originally posted by valrod33:
Im not clicking on your links anymore after your NBA mock draft


I admit im not the biggest NBA guy and I did the NBA draft mock just for fun.

How is Ray Lewis all the way down at number 10? and more puzzling is how is Urlacher that high? London Fletcher should be moved up aswell. And having Franklin over Hampton is crazy. I would probably move Justin Smith up a bit. Overall looks pretty good.
Originally posted by PatrickJira411:
Originally posted by jreff22:
Rodgers is to high
McNabb is to low
Grant is to high
Where is Barber
Avery shouldn't even be on that list
Rice is to high
TE's are good
Swap Long and Thomas
I would put J Allen at the top of the list
J Smith is a lil low for my homerism
Move Mayo and Lewis up


Ronde Barber? I think he is pretty much washed up. Appreciate all the feedback though, thanks.

Marion Barber
  • KRS-1
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 26,956
Crabtree @ 19 ?

And ahead of Santonio Holmes ?
Originally posted by lamontb:
How is Ray Lewis all the way down at number 10? and more puzzling is how is Urlacher that high? London Fletcher should be moved up aswell. And having Franklin over Hampton is crazy. I would probably move Justin Smith up a bit. Overall looks pretty good.


He is still a great leader and good vs the run but he is a major liability in pass coverage now and is even attacked by opposing teams as before teams stayed away from him. Casey Hampton is on the downside of his career, IMO
Originally posted by KRS-1:
Crabtree @ 19 ?

And ahead of Santonio Holmes ?


Let me know how you feel about that in December
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by PatrickJira411:
Originally posted by jreff22:
Rodgers is to high
McNabb is to low
Grant is to high
Where is Barber
Avery shouldn't even be on that list
Rice is to high
TE's are good
Swap Long and Thomas
I would put J Allen at the top of the list
J Smith is a lil low for my homerism
Move Mayo and Lewis up


Ronde Barber? I think he is pretty much washed up. Appreciate all the feedback though, thanks.

Marion Barber


Decline and may be the 3rd best RB on his team this year. I think he will be a goal-line and short yardage back for the most part this year.
  • KRS-1
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 26,956
Originally posted by PatrickJira411:
Originally posted by KRS-1:
Crabtree @ 19 ?

And ahead of Santonio Holmes ?


Let me know how you feel about that in December

Holmes will be playing in at least 4 less games and also has 2 other solid receivers whom will cut into his pass attempts so Crabtree better have better production in December. However production can be overrated as well.

So these rankings must be totally based off of upside whilst barely accounting for said players play from last year.
  • crzy
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,280
Jamaal Charles will be a top 5 RB in the league by the end of the year
Originally posted by KRS-1:
Originally posted by PatrickJira411:
Originally posted by KRS-1:
Crabtree @ 19 ?

And ahead of Santonio Holmes ?


Let me know how you feel about that in December

Holmes will be playing in at least 4 less games and also has 2 other solid receivers whom will cut into his pass attempts so Crabtree better have better production in December. However production can be overrated as well.

So these rankings must be totally based off of upside whilst barely accounting for said players play from last year.


Both. Crabtree closed real well last season and I think he will only get better while the Steelers could not wait to get rid of Holmes. Simply put, I think Crabtree will be a better NFL WR than Holmes this year and beyond.