Originally posted by ImaMod:
Matt Shaub (same production with a worse team but a great WR)
It helps having the best Wide Receiver in the league to throw to. All he has to do is throw it up and Johnson will come down with it. Think Daunte Culpepper when he had Randy Moss.
Eli Manning- He already has won the superbowl, his starting RB is always injured, WAAY more accurate, his D sucked so its not his fault his team sucked, no great WR, and when he had a good D and great WR, he won a damn superbowl
I like Eli, but he won the Superbowl BECAUSE he had a great defense. That defense help the highest scoring offense to 14 points. And I dont know how you say Eli is more accurate than Aaron Rodgers when Eli's highest Completion percentage is less than Aaron's career average completion percentage.