I'd sure as hell would prefer Atogwe over Goldson right now.
Atogwe has proven he's a top 15 safety for the past 4 years. Goldson has had injury problems and couldn't beat Mark Roman out for the first two years of his career.
Sure Goldson has more long-term potential due to his age, but you'd be crazy not to take a hard look at Atogwe if he becomes available.
Right now, Goldson has the highest chance of being a one year wonder in terms of his playmaking skills and health.
Additionally, I wouldn't mind cutting Reggie Smith, signing Atogwe as the FS, and using Goldson as the 3rd S and substitute on pass downs ala Ahmed Brooks. It adds more talent to the secondary, and allows Mays to use this year to understand the real nuances of the game, and impact special teams.