First you have to see if his neck is really healed. They are talking about nerves need time to regenerate and heal. And loss of arm strength. Doesn't sound good. Obviously if he is healthy you would be out of your mind not to want him for say 3 years. This team is pre made for Peyton Manning. Powerhouse defense, normally great special teams, bruising O line, good RB's, VD, Crab (a little overrated but ok).
Wow. Why couldn't Peyton Manning succeed with this? I like Alex and the progress he's made. But if you get a shot at this you may be the Super Bowl favorite for 3 years in a row. And maybe win 1 or 2. I'd go after him if he is healthy. But I think that is a big if. A very big if.