I like both as football players though...I have always felt that the Giants lucked out getting in Plex at that initial contract.....he is a real good player......and I wanted the 49ers to get him the first time when he left the Steelers....then a second time he was available.
I like Vick because I still remember that game at Green Bay, just like Alex fans remember the series of plays in Seattle they always talk about
.....but seriously Vick has had a good NFL career playing wise....some still believe that he still looks to run first....but that is not necessary the case...his first couple of years maybe. As far as the 49ers go...I think we should bring him in, and have him serve as a third string back-up or take a roster spot as a 5th WR.....I like Shaun Hill and I believe he will do great this year....but if for some reason he does, I'd like to see what Vick would do in this offenses....I think it would be PERFECT for him, with these players we have.
But if Shaun does great like I expect him to, then we can use Vick as trade bait late in the year to a team that might want to experiment with him for next year...
in a controlled offense IMO
Vick 2 yrs ago and now > Alex
Vick 2 yrs ago and maybe now > Huard