Originally posted by dtg_9er:
From CBS Prospect Overviews:
Shelton: "What makes Shelton unique is his effort in pursuit. It wasn't uncommon for Shelton to sprint to the sideline or 10-plus yards downfield to stop ballcarriers."
Goldman: "Though the junior again didn't post the kind of statistics (35 tackles, eight tackles for loss and four sacks in 13 regular-season starts) to attract a lot of hype, his steady development, proven versatility and NFL-ready frame make him one of the most intriguing defensive tackle prospects in the country."
Not sure Goldman sounds better than Shelton, other than he looks the part. Would like to see more productive career.
I read the CBS prospect overviews as well and it sounds like Shelton may have a higher floor but lower ceiling. It doesn't sound like he has the length or athleticism of Goldman or is expected to be as effective of a pass rusher in the pros. CBS has them rated #19 and #20 (Shelton is #19) currently, but I could see teams talking themselves out of getting Shelton if he doesn't perform well at the combine. Shelton may be the safer pick - he's a big body with a high motor, but Goldman has more physical tools that can be developed. Goldman was buried in the rotation at Florida State and hasn't developed as much.
From CBS Prospect Overviews:
Shelton:
WEAKNESSES: Not the pass rusher that his statistics indicate, showing little more than a standard bull-rush. Rarely incorporates spins or even swim moves into his repertoire.
Pad level rises as he tires and he can get knocked off the line of scrimmage when double-teamers coordinate their efforts and don't allow Shelton to split them. Needs to show greater awareness of cut blocks.
Tackle numbers are inflated by his hustling in pursuit. Weight needs to be held in check.
Despite his production indicating otherwise, Shelton is not a consistent pass rush threat. He's a classic two-gap run-plugger with the bulk and brute strength to bull-rush opponents into the backfield.
Goldman:
WEAKNESSES: Though quicker than he looks, Goldman isn't a consistent pass rush threat. His broad build makes it difficult for him to squeeze through gaps and he shows just phone-booth quickness. Generally needs a clear lane and collides with ballcarriers rather than exploding into them.
Still working on some of the finer details of position, including getting his hands up more often to knock down passes at the line of scrimmage and improved his recognition of cut-blocks. Surrounded by a lot of talent and was used as part of a rotation.
Lael Collins is a good one. Her be very solid, and could play multiple positions on the line.
