There are 62 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

I Have a GREAT Draft Trade Idea For Balke!!!

Trade #30 + #56 + #94 to the Titans for #11 Overall and Draft CB Justin Gilbert or CB Darqueze Denard. One of those guys should be there at #11.

That would give the 49ers CB Gilbert/Denard, still would have #61,#77,#100,#129,#170,#242,#243,#245

We'd still be able to snatch a WR Prospect,DE Prospect,Guard/Center Prospect,Safety Prospect.

I Just feel that Denard or Gilbert would FIT right in and start immediately.
Originally posted by ElephantHaley:
Trade #30 + #56 + #94 to the Titans for #11 Overall and Draft CB Justin Gilbert or CB Darqueze Denard. One of those guys should be there at #11.

That would give the 49ers CB Gilbert/Denard, still would have #61,#77,#100,#129,#170,#242,#243,#245

We'd still be able to snatch a WR Prospect,DE Prospect,Guard/Center Prospect,Safety Prospect.

I Just feel that Denard or Gilbert would FIT right in and start immediately.

Its all about the trade offs. I think guys like Fuller, Roby, and Verrett would contribute just as much as Dennard and Gilbert.
But in this system you would lose our other picks, limiting other players chances to come in and make a difference. Its a solid idea, I just don't know if I would want to throw away draft picks for a draft this deep.

This year is strange because there isn't much difference talent wise between 1-10 rankings in most positions this year.
So this would have been smart maybe last year? Or next year? But not this year,

who knows I've also been wrong before.
Still waiting for this great idea you speak of....

Seriously tho, I don't think Dennard or Gilbert are worth trading that far up for. I'd rather stay put and roll with Verrett or Fuller. Just my opinion.
Id do that for Gilbert, I prefer him over Dennard... I'm going to try to do a mock soon where he falls to the Titans and we trade.
We can get value at thirty to address the secondary. If Watkins or Evans drop that far it becomes a more worthwhile move up.
How about 30 + 61 + 100 instead
Neither Gilbert nor Dennard is worth that trade up. If the 49ers could pull off the same deal as they did last yeat for Reid and pick up Dennard around 18 or so, I'd support that. Beyond that, better to stand pat and take Fuller or Verrett.
I like the idea of being aggressive. If Gilbert or Dennard are the guy's Baalke decides on, I want to see him make sure he gets who he wants. Thats all I really ask, a pro-active approach to the draft , controlling our own destiny instead of just selecting whatever is left. That's what worked last year with Reid. Fans tend to view things in absolutes, no one really knows who is going to be a baller or not.
Again this draft is toooooooo freaking deep to trade that many picks away. Fuller and Verrett are very capable CB's the 49ers can take at #30.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Neither Gilbert nor Dennard is worth that trade up. If the 49ers could pull off the same deal as they did last yeat for Reid and pick up Dennard around 18 or so, I'd support that. Beyond that, better to stand pat and take Fuller or Verrett.

I completely agree but I believe it'll cost much more this year to move up in the teens...unless it's with Jerry Jones.
There are always players that fall for some reason. If a wr or cb falls into the 20s then go after him with a trade.
Originally posted by JDMathews49ers:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Neither Gilbert nor Dennard is worth that trade up. If the 49ers could pull off the same deal as they did last yeat for Reid and pick up Dennard around 18 or so, I'd support that. Beyond that, better to stand pat and take Fuller or Verrett.

I completely agree but I believe it'll cost much more this year to move up in the teens...unless it's with Jerry Jones.

Cowboys have do many holes trading down for them will be good they need more picks
There are PLENTY of spots available on this team.
Do you really believe in the statements below? Because that is essentially what people are saying if they think we can't use multiple draft picks.

QB - "Oh God no, we can't lose McCoy!"
FB - "Stop it. Tukuafu is essential to the team."
2 WR - "Please no, what will we do without Baldwin and Osgood?"
TE - "Celek can't be cut, he is a monster."
G - "Are you loony? We can't cut Looney!"
C - "Kilgore is the answer at center, he has proven this over many years of not seeing the field."

3 CB - "Wright, Morris, and Cox cannot leave this team. They are the cornerstones of our defense"
SS - "Doh! We can't lose Dahl!"
FS - "Spillman must remain on the team, for the love of Pete."
DE - "NO! Not Dobbs, anyone but Dobbs!"
2 MLB - "Moody and Wilhoite are essential and cannot be replaced."

15 spots available.
[ Edited by BrianGO on Apr 2, 2014 at 10:42 PM ]
Originally posted by BrianGO:
There are PLENTY of spots available on this team.
Do you really believe in the statements below? Because that is essentially what people are saying if they think we can't use multiple draft picks.

QB - "Oh God no, we can't lose McCoy!"
FB - "Stop it. Tukuafu is essential to the team."
2 WR - "Please no, what will we do without Baldwin and Osgood?"
TE - "Celek can't be cut, he is a monster."
G - "Are you loony? We can't cut Looney!"
C - "Kilgore is the answer at center, he has proven this over many years of not seeing the field."

3 CB - "Wright, Morris, and Cox cannot leave this team. They are the cornerstones of our defense"
SS - "Doh! We can't lose Dahl!"
FS - "Spillman must remain on the team, for the love of Pete."
DE - "NO! Not Dobbs, anyone but Dobbs!"
2 MLB - "Moody and Wilhoite are essential and cannot be replaced."

15 spots available.

Ah dude don't bash on my dude Tukuafa!
He was a beast in the playoffs!
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 20,918
Like someone else mentioned. This draft is too deep to be trading away picks. I'd rather just stay put and get someone with equal value where we're picking.