Originally posted by jreff22:
What you need to know is an A means perfection....did you miss that idea in school? A's are the hardest grade to achieve and are only given out when everything is perfect or near perfect.
Enough time has passed for tempers to have reduced somewhat.
First, an A does NOT mean perfection nor near perfection.
B = very good
C = good
F = unacceptable
When a team picks a All Pro player in the 3rd round or lower, extra value needs to be assigned.
I would use an A+ plus grade for Bowman. This is similar to the extra value assigned for honor courses.
The grading should be on the player's overall performance in the league not just performance for the team that drafted him.
If a player is still playing in the league after 3 years, an F is not an acceptable grade.
If two players have performed more or less equally, and one player was drafted in the 2nd round and the other in the 6th, the grade assigned to the 6th round player should be higher.