Originally posted by WillistheWall:in general, even if i the qb is the most important position in this game, i wouldnt rank an above-avg qb-prospect (who COULD be a help in the future) over a patrick peterson, who would make an impact from day one. same goes for AJ green.Originally posted by communist:Originally posted by WillistheWall:i'm sorry but looking back and have a look at the ranking before the regarding draft is a BIG difference.
I am surprised that so many people hate these rankings he does. I mean if you look back at past drafts and you had Aaron Rodgers/Frank Gore ranked 1-2 for that 05 draft people would kill you. If you listed TO in his draft as a top 10 guy, people would've looked at you like youre nuts. Guys always surprise later in the draft and inevitably some guys in the first few rounds bust, he is simply guessing as to who this surprises and leaving out guys he feels will bust.
Yeah but he already said this isn't a mock or big board or anything based on value. He said this is his own PERSONAL RANKING OF WHO HE THINKS WILL TURN OUT WELL. Like I said before, there are plenty of guys like Gore who people would've thought you were crazy if you said "these guys will be the best or 2nd best player out of their draft class". Now are some of the rankins questionable? Yeah but so is every ranking. The fact that everyone just wants to stick to the experts boards and stuff and doesn't have their own ranking tells me that most fans don't have the ability to evaluate these guys and haven't seen anything in most of these players. Atleast he is willing to go out on a limb and take some shots on players he believes in. Come up with your own ranking if you think his sucks, don't just criticize him for having a ranking.
[ Edited by communist on Mar 1, 2011 at 7:28 PM ]