There are 131 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

What's Your QB 'Big Board'?

What's your 'Big Board' for Quarterbacks and the round you value them at? Here's mine -- I have Nick Foles as the #5 QB, even though he's probably coming bck for 2011:

1. Andrew Luck, Stanford - Top 3 Pick
2. Jake Locker, Washington - Top 10 Pick
3. Ryan Mallett, Arkansas - Top 10 Pick
4. Cam Netwon, Auburn - Top 20 Pick
*5. NIck Foles, Arizona - borderline 1st round, early 2nd
6. Christian Ponder, Florida State - 2nd Round
7. Pat Devlin, Delaware - 3rd Round
8. Ricki Stanzi, Iowa - 3rd/4th Round
1. Andrew Luck, Stanford - #1 overall
2. Ryan Mallett, Arkansas - Top 10
3. Cam Newton, Auburn - Top 20
4. Jake Locker, Washington - 1st rounder
*5. Nick Foles, Arizona - early 2nd rounder
6. Christian Ponder, Florida State - 2nd rounder
7. Ricky Stanzi, Iowa - 2nd rounder
*8. Terrelle Pryor, Ohio State - 2nd/3rd rounder
9. Pat Devlin, Delaware - 2nd/3rd rounder
10. Colin Kaepernick, Nevada - 3rd/4th rounder
[ Edited by GhostofFredDean74 on Dec 23, 2010 at 10:09 AM ]
Nick Foles plans on returning

Andrew Luck, Stanford, So

Cameron Newton, Auburn, Jr.

Ryan Mallett, Arkansas, Jr.

Jake Locker, Washington

Ricky Stanzi, Iowa

Christian Ponder, Florida St.

Andy Dalton, TCU

Pat Devlin, Delaware

Blaine Gabbert, Missouri, Jr.

Colin Kaepernick, Nevada

Nathan Enderle, Idaho

Greg McElroy, Alabama

Case Keenum , Houston

Jerrod Johnson, Texas A&M

Tyrod Taylor, Virginia Tech
[ Edited by ChaunceyGardner on Dec 23, 2010 at 10:20 AM ]
I want no part of Ponder or Mallett. Mallett is too inaccurate, and Ponder is just like every other FSU QB.
How many QB threads you gonna start?
Originally posted by nickbradley:
What's your 'Big Board' for Quarterbacks and the round you value them at? Here's mine -- I have Nick Foles as the #5 QB, even though he's probably coming bck for 2011:

1. Andrew Luck, Stanford - Top 3 Pick
2. Jake Locker, Washington - Top 10 Pick
3. Ryan Mallett, Arkansas - Top 10 Pick
4. Cam Netwon, Auburn - Top 20 Pick
*5. NIck Foles, Arizona - borderline 1st round, early 2nd
6. Christian Ponder, Florida State - 2nd Round
7. Pat Devlin, Delaware - 3rd Round
8. Ricki Stanzi, Iowa - 3rd/4th Round

Can you explain Locker at 2????????? Cant even break 60% completion %. Know the law of 60 my son, know it well. he was dreadful this year, injury and no injury. I see him 3rd or 4th based on athleticism alone.
1. Andrew Luck - 1st round
2. Cam Newton 1st round
3 I have no clue
Originally posted by jojomellon:
Originally posted by nickbradley:
What's your 'Big Board' for Quarterbacks and the round you value them at? Here's mine -- I have Nick Foles as the #5 QB, even though he's probably coming bck for 2011:

1. Andrew Luck, Stanford - Top 3 Pick
2. Jake Locker, Washington - Top 10 Pick
3. Ryan Mallett, Arkansas - Top 10 Pick
4. Cam Netwon, Auburn - Top 20 Pick
*5. NIck Foles, Arizona - borderline 1st round, early 2nd
6. Christian Ponder, Florida State - 2nd Round
7. Pat Devlin, Delaware - 3rd Round
8. Ricki Stanzi, Iowa - 3rd/4th Round

Can you explain Locker at 2????????? Cant even break 60% completion %. Know the law of 60 my son, know it well. he was dreadful this year, injury and no injury. I see him 3rd or 4th based on athleticism alone.

Nah, Locker wont be a top 10 pick be he will go in the 1st round. I think Stanzi's stock will rise also.
Why does everyone like Devlin? Could someone tell me whats so good about him?
  • KRS-1
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 29,614
Originally posted by jreff22:
How many QB threads you gonna start?

[font=sarcasm]We need MORE QB threads, at least 2 for each eligible QB plus a bunch of generalized ones. [/font]
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
1. Andrew Luck, Stanford - #1 overall
2. Ryan Mallett, Arkansas - Top 10
3. Cam Newton, Auburn - Top 20
4. Jake Locker, Washington - 1st rounder
*5. Nick Foles, Arizona - early 2nd rounder
6. Christian Ponder, Florida State - 2nd rounder
7. Ricky Stanzi, Iowa - 2nd rounder
*8. Terrelle Pryor, Ohio State - 2nd/3rd rounder
9. Pat Devlin, Delaware - 2nd/3rd rounder
10. Colin Kaepernick, Nevada - 3rd/4th rounder

Based on your predictions for available QB going 2nd or later would you rather address Defensive Secondary in the first round or go for the talent the 1st has to offer and take a QB there? just trying to gauge others fans opions cuz im on the fence about it.
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
1. Andrew Luck, Stanford - #1 overall
2. Ryan Mallett, Arkansas - Top 10
3. Cam Newton, Auburn - Top 20
4. Jake Locker, Washington - 1st rounder
*5. Nick Foles, Arizona - early 2nd rounder
6. Christian Ponder, Florida State - 2nd rounder
7. Ricky Stanzi, Iowa - 2nd rounder
*8. Terrelle Pryor, Ohio State - 2nd/3rd rounder
9. Pat Devlin, Delaware - 2nd/3rd rounder
10. Colin Kaepernick, Nevada - 3rd/4th rounder

I think this is pretty fair. The only guys I want in the 1st round are Locker, Luck or Mallett. The others I wouldn't pick there.

I really like Kaepernick as a dark horse later in the draft. He's tall and athletic. IMO his arm is underrated. He's pretty accurate when I've watched him. I wouldn't even mind Pryor later. He's a heck of an athlete. The arm is pretty good.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
1. Andrew Luck, Stanford - #1 overall
2. Ryan Mallett, Arkansas - Top 10
3. Cam Newton, Auburn - Top 20
4. Jake Locker, Washington - 1st rounder
*5. Nick Foles, Arizona - early 2nd rounder
6. Christian Ponder, Florida State - 2nd rounder
7. Ricky Stanzi, Iowa - 2nd rounder
*8. Terrelle Pryor, Ohio State - 2nd/3rd rounder
9. Pat Devlin, Delaware - 2nd/3rd rounder
10. Colin Kaepernick, Nevada - 3rd/4th rounder

I think this is pretty fair. The only guys I want in the 1st round are Locker, Luck or Mallett. The others I wouldn't pick there.

I really like Kaepernick as a dark horse later in the draft. He's tall and athletic. IMO his arm is underrated. He's pretty accurate when I've watched him. I wouldn't even mind Pryor later. He's a heck of an athlete. The arm is pretty good.

I agree uwth all of this except I would take Kaepernick ahead of Pryor and probably Devlin
Originally posted by jreff22:
How many QB threads you gonna start?

There's at least 4
Originally posted by WillisToHOF:
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
1. Andrew Luck, Stanford - #1 overall
2. Ryan Mallett, Arkansas - Top 10
3. Cam Newton, Auburn - Top 20
4. Jake Locker, Washington - 1st rounder
*5. Nick Foles, Arizona - early 2nd rounder
6. Christian Ponder, Florida State - 2nd rounder
7. Ricky Stanzi, Iowa - 2nd rounder
*8. Terrelle Pryor, Ohio State - 2nd/3rd rounder
9. Pat Devlin, Delaware - 2nd/3rd rounder
10. Colin Kaepernick, Nevada - 3rd/4th rounder

Based on your predictions for available QB going 2nd or later would you rather address Defensive Secondary in the first round or go for the talent the 1st has to offer and take a QB there? just trying to gauge others fans opions cuz im on the fence about it.

If we secure a veteran QB to run the team for a year or two, I'd prefer to use the 1st rounder on the best available CB or pass rusher, then use our 2nd rounder on a developmental QB.