Please do me a favor and look up some mock drafts done WITH Andrew Luck. Most of the recent ones were done around the Bowl games. Mallett was more or less the consensus #2 QB around that time going anywhere from #2-#15 in the first round.
Yet now 4 months later, no games played and he's dropped to round 2, even 3... Because he was arrested for PI when he was 20?
The guy has better stats than Peyton Manning did in his final year playing in the same SEC, yet he's a poor decision maker?
For the haters, try reading this article with an open mind and perhaps you will change your stance:
http://weblogs.sun-sentinel.com/sports/columnists/hyde/blog/2011/03/draft_winds_lies_damn_lies_and_1.html