There are 172 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Still Think Scotty Mac was Good for this Team?

Kentawn Balmer over DeSean Jackson, Ray Rice, or Kenny Phillips
Chilo Rachal over the first two mentioned above
Joe Staley for the #7 pick in the draft
Glen Coffee
Cody Wallace
Traded A 5th for Ted Ginn when it could have been Santonio Holmes. (we had a Higher Pick than the Jets and in the other conference)
I think Nolan might have been a better talent evaluator minus Smith over Rodgers
Sincerely,
FK the Yorks
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Kentawn Balmer over DeSean Jackson, Ray Rice, or Kenny Phillips
Chilo Rachal over the first two mentioned above
Joe Staley for the #7 pick in the draft
Glen Coffee
Cody Wallace
Traded A 5th for Ted Ginn when it could have been Santonio Holmes. (we had a Higher Pick than the Jets and in the other conference)
I think Nolan might have been a better talent evaluator minus Smith over Rodgers
Sincerely,
FK the Yorks

I think Baalke traded the 5th for Ginn
Originally posted by theginz2004:
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Kentawn Balmer over DeSean Jackson, Ray Rice, or Kenny Phillips
Chilo Rachal over the first two mentioned above
Joe Staley for the #7 pick in the draft
Glen Coffee
Cody Wallace
Traded A 5th for Ted Ginn when it could have been Santonio Holmes. (we had a Higher Pick than the Jets and in the other conference)
I think Nolan might have been a better talent evaluator minus Smith over Rodgers
Sincerely,
FK the Yorks

I think Baalke traded the 5th for Ginn

no it was before Mac was fired
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Originally posted by theginz2004:
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Kentawn Balmer over DeSean Jackson, Ray Rice, or Kenny Phillips
Chilo Rachal over the first two mentioned above
Joe Staley for the #7 pick in the draft
Glen Coffee
Cody Wallace
Traded A 5th for Ted Ginn when it could have been Santonio Holmes. (we had a Higher Pick than the Jets and in the other conference)
I think Nolan might have been a better talent evaluator minus Smith over Rodgers
Sincerely,
FK the Yorks

I think Baalke traded the 5th for Ginn

no it was before Mac was fired

Scot McCloughan resigned March 19th, 2010. (Source)
Ted Ginn Jr. acquired April 16th, 2010. (Source)

We can also play this game with Bill Walsh (or any General Manager), if you'd like.

Selected Reggie McGrew over Patrick Kerney, Jon Jansen or Joey Porter.
Traded up for Ahmed Plummer, losing future picks in 2001.
Giovanni Carmazzi
Jason Webster
Jamie Winborn
Kevan Barlow

And we can go back to when Walsh was the Head Coach ('79 - '88).

Selected James Owens over Dan Ross, Fred Smerlas and Mark Gastineau.
Earl Cooper
Jim Stuckey
Craig Puki
John Harty
Blanchard Montgomery
Todd Shell
Ricky Moore
Terrence Flagler
Jeff Bregel
Keith Delong
Keith Henderson

I could keep going, but I need to take lunch.

Let me know if you want me to name more.
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Kentawn Balmer over DeSean Jackson, Ray Rice, or Kenny Phillips
Chilo Rachal over the first two mentioned above
Joe Staley for the #7 pick in the draft
Glen Coffee
Cody Wallace
Traded A 5th for Ted Ginn when it could have been Santonio Holmes. (we had a Higher Pick than the Jets and in the other conference)
I think Nolan might have been a better talent evaluator minus Smith over Rodgers
Sincerely,
FK the Yorks

yeah they were some bad picks but you can't forget about willis,davis,and most importantly gore in the third round.It works both ways.
Originally posted by redrathman:
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Originally posted by theginz2004:
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Kentawn Balmer over DeSean Jackson, Ray Rice, or Kenny Phillips
Chilo Rachal over the first two mentioned above
Joe Staley for the #7 pick in the draft
Glen Coffee
Cody Wallace
Traded A 5th for Ted Ginn when it could have been Santonio Holmes. (we had a Higher Pick than the Jets and in the other conference)
I think Nolan might have been a better talent evaluator minus Smith over Rodgers
Sincerely,
FK the Yorks

I think Baalke traded the 5th for Ginn

no it was before Mac was fired

Scot McCloughan resigned March 19th, 2010. (Source)
Ted Ginn Jr. acquired April 16th, 2010. (Source)

We can also play this game with Bill Walsh (or any General Manager), if you'd like.

Selected Reggie McGrew over Patrick Kerney, Jon Jansen or Joey Porter.
Traded up for Ahmed Plummer, losing future picks in 2001.
Giovanni Carmazzi
Jason Webster
Jamie Winborn
Kevan Barlow

And we can go back to when Walsh was the Head Coach ('79 - '88).

Selected James Owens over Dan Ross, Fred Smerlas and Mark Gastineau.
Earl Cooper
Jim Stuckey
Craig Puki
John Harty
Blanchard Montgomery
Todd Shell
Ricky Moore
Terrence Flagler
Jeff Bregel
Keith Delong
Keith Henderson

I could keep going, but I need to take lunch.

Let me know if you want me to name more.

For Bill Walsh's Great Equalizer He was able to Identify HOF QB's, which is the hardest thing to do so he was given a free pass sometimes.......what you said about Carmazzi, that was an absolute lie. Walsh wanted TOM BRADY instead of CARMAZZI but Donahue and Mooch wanted Carmazzi....Mooch admitted this. Just Imagine if we had listened to BW in his last years
Originally posted by YorkHater:
For Bill Walsh's Great Equalizer He was able to Identify HOF QB's, which is the hardest thing to do so he was given a free pass sometimes.......what you said about Carmazzi, that was an absolute lie. Walsh wanted TOM BRADY instead of CARMAZZI but Donahue and Mooch wanted Carmazzi....Mooch admitted this. Just Imagine if we had listened to BW in his last years

I haven't ever heard this. Walsh was the GM and he had final say over the draft and personnel decisions.

Get me a source and then come at me.
http://warroom.sportingnews.com/nfl/articles/20041231/589950-p.html

17th paragraph
Originally posted by YorkHater:
http://warroom.sportingnews.com/nfl/articles/20041231/589950-p.html

17th paragraph

Mariucci isn't quoted as having selected Carmazzi. The passage states that neither wanted to take the blame for the pick.

Try again.
Some of that was Nolan too. I think people forget that for awhile there Nolan had first say on what was going on.
that 5th round pick trade for Ginn was a great trade
and Holmes went for a 4th round pick which we didnt have.. not a 5th round pick

Plus that was Baalkes move anyways
Originally posted by redrathman:
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Originally posted by theginz2004:
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Kentawn Balmer over DeSean Jackson, Ray Rice, or Kenny Phillips
Chilo Rachal over the first two mentioned above
Joe Staley for the #7 pick in the draft
Glen Coffee
Cody Wallace
Traded A 5th for Ted Ginn when it could have been Santonio Holmes. (we had a Higher Pick than the Jets and in the other conference)
I think Nolan might have been a better talent evaluator minus Smith over Rodgers
Sincerely,
FK the Yorks

I think Baalke traded the 5th for Ginn

no it was before Mac was fired

Scot McCloughan resigned March 19th, 2010. (Source)
Ted Ginn Jr. acquired April 16th, 2010. (Source)

We can also play this game with Bill Walsh (or any General Manager), if you'd like.

Selected Reggie McGrew over Patrick Kerney, Jon Jansen or Joey Porter.
Traded up for Ahmed Plummer, losing future picks in 2001.
Giovanni Carmazzi
Jason Webster
Jamie Winborn
Kevan Barlow

And we can go back to when Walsh was the Head Coach ('79 - '88).

Selected James Owens over Dan Ross, Fred Smerlas and Mark Gastineau.
Earl Cooper
Jim Stuckey
Craig Puki
John Harty
Blanchard Montgomery
Todd Shell
Ricky Moore
Terrence Flagler
Jeff Bregel
Keith Delong
Keith Henderson

I could keep going, but I need to take lunch.

Let me know if you want me to name more.

good post
no Gm is perfect..
He also got us
Frank Gore in the 3rd round
Patrick Willis
Vernon Davis
Michael Crabtree
Joe staley..overrated imo though
Was he GM when we got Justin Smith?

Matt Millen though.. that is a terrible GM
Originally posted by redrathman:
Originally posted by YorkHater:
http://warroom.sportingnews.com/nfl/articles/20041231/589950-p.html

17th paragraph

Mariucci isn't quoted as having selected Carmazzi. The passage states that neither wanted to take the blame for the pick.

Try again.

We all know that Mariucci wanted Carmazzi no matter what any article says.
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Originally posted by theginz2004:
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Kentawn Balmer over DeSean Jackson, Ray Rice, or Kenny Phillips
Chilo Rachal over the first two mentioned above
Joe Staley for the #7 pick in the draft
Glen Coffee
Cody Wallace
Traded A 5th for Ted Ginn when it could have been Santonio Holmes. (we had a Higher Pick than the Jets and in the other conference)
I think Nolan might have been a better talent evaluator minus Smith over Rodgers
Sincerely,
FK the Yorks

I think Baalke traded the 5th for Ginn

no it was before Mac was fired

FAIL
Originally posted by CrAnKD4TCRabTree:
Originally posted by redrathman:
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Originally posted by theginz2004:
Originally posted by YorkHater:
Kentawn Balmer over DeSean Jackson, Ray Rice, or Kenny Phillips
Chilo Rachal over the first two mentioned above
Joe Staley for the #7 pick in the draft
Glen Coffee
Cody Wallace
Traded A 5th for Ted Ginn when it could have been Santonio Holmes. (we had a Higher Pick than the Jets and in the other conference)
I think Nolan might have been a better talent evaluator minus Smith over Rodgers
Sincerely,
FK the Yorks

I think Baalke traded the 5th for Ginn

no it was before Mac was fired

Scot McCloughan resigned March 19th, 2010. (Source)
Ted Ginn Jr. acquired April 16th, 2010. (Source)

We can also play this game with Bill Walsh (or any General Manager), if you'd like.

Selected Reggie McGrew over Patrick Kerney, Jon Jansen or Joey Porter.
Traded up for Ahmed Plummer, losing future picks in 2001.
Giovanni Carmazzi
Jason Webster
Jamie Winborn
Kevan Barlow

And we can go back to when Walsh was the Head Coach ('79 - '88).

Selected James Owens over Dan Ross, Fred Smerlas and Mark Gastineau.
Earl Cooper
Jim Stuckey
Craig Puki
John Harty
Blanchard Montgomery
Todd Shell
Ricky Moore
Terrence Flagler
Jeff Bregel
Keith Delong
Keith Henderson

I could keep going, but I need to take lunch.

Let me know if you want me to name more.

good post
no Gm is perfect..
He also got us
Frank Gore in the 3rd round
Patrick Willis
Vernon Davis
Michael Crabtree
Joe staley..overrated imo though
Was he GM when we got Justin Smith?

Matt Millen though.. that is a terrible GM

how many probowlers