There are 166 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Todd McShay

For whatever reason, McShay believes Kindle will be "as impactfull" as a Demarcus Ware, Jared Allen rushing the passer. Also, he has it that he is our #1 need at 13.

I am not familiar at all with Kindle, or any OLB ranked 1-4, for other needs, respectfully. Can anyone throw some input my way on him and his potential?
TX9R would be the best to answer that.

For general info:
Read & React: A chase-down player who attacks and plays very well when free to roam. Excellent closing speed to the ball and strong reaction once a ballcarrier makes his move. Relies on his athleticism too much and his instincts are questionable. Will overrun plays and can be fooled by misdirection. Could improve his awareness by keeping eyes in the backfield when rushing the passer.

Run defense: Has the length and change-of-direction agility to hold the corner. Closes down the line well, and has improved his willingness to chase downfield. Must improve his ability to disengage from blocks of NFL-caliber tackles, or even tight ends, on the edge. Strong enough to hold his ground on run plays and stand up in the trash when fresh, but his lack of bulk causes him to tire quickly when playing every down. Will run around blocks at times. Athletic enough to avoid cuts but doesn't always use his hands well.

Pass defense: His speed and length stops receivers and backs in their tracks on screen passes to at least force them inside. Quick enough to stay with tight ends in the flat or down the seam. A step late catching bootlegs run toward him, and not quite smooth or agile enough to make up ground. Brings down receivers quickly when dropping into zone from linebacker spot. Needs work on route recognition. Knocks down passes on the line and in coverage using his long arms, but does not have great hands for the interception.

Tackling: Has very good closing speed. Difficult to avoid in space as he can break down and quickly change direction. Has the length to wrap up ballcarriers in the open field or shut down the edge after getting off outside blocks. Strong enough to arm-tackle backs and receivers. Proved more than capable on special teams early in his career because of his size and speed.

Pass Rush/Blitz: Owns prototypical height, length and speed for an elite pass rusher. Quick off the snap whether lined up with his hand down or standing up. Explodes into quarterback. Can turn the corner and square to the quarterback quickly. Flashes a bull rush against tackles, but does not get off straight-on blocks to get secondary pressure. Stops his rush effort after initial contact. Gets picked up by running backs too easily, tries to dance around them instead of attacking.

Intangibles: Nagging injuries, off-field issues and inconsistency are red flags to scouts. A quiet leader in the locker room who doesn't act out when things are down or let negative press get to him.

Kindle started 25-of-46 games at Texas, including 11 at strong-side linebacker and fifteen at defensive end … His official NCAA statistics read, 151 tackles (106 solos), 16.5 sacks for minus-120 yards, 33.5 stops for losses of 166 yards and 18 quarterback pressures … Caused three fumbles and recovered three others … Also deflected five passes and blocked a kick … Added 14 tackles (nine solo) for the special team coverage unit.
Todd McShay is a f*g
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 15,097
Todd McShay is the worst draft "expert", maybe ever, Not sure why ESPN keeps him around... I guess its to say stupid things to piss Kiper off.
[ Edited by Jcool on Apr 17, 2010 at 11:36 AM ]
Originally posted by chico49erfan:
Todd McShay is a f*g


This
Originally posted by chico49erfan:
Todd McShay is a f*g
Todd McGay
[ Edited by DaDivaRecieva15 on Apr 17, 2010 at 11:37 AM ]
Todd McShay gets his intel from player agents, not GMs and NFL scouts. He is really lousy at evaluating talent and matching players to a team's system and needs.

As much as people like to bust on Kiper, he really does know his business. I also like Mike Mayock and Michael Lombardi, who is a Walsh disciple.
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Todd McShay gets his intel from player agents, not GMs and NFL scouts. He is really lousy at evaluating talent and matching players to a team's system and needs.

As much as people like to bust on Kiper, he really does know his business. I also like Mike Mayock and Michael Lombardi, who is a Walsh disciple.

Word on the block is that McShay has burned a lot of bridges with coaches, scouts and GM's, Kiper did the same back in the day but has since rebuilt those bridges. McShay has a knack for rubbing people the wrong way.
Originally posted by mrbusinessman499:
Originally posted by chico49erfan:
Todd McShay is a f*g


This
i try to give these draft "experts" the benefit of the doubt, but everytime i hear mcshay talk its like he is saying things just for shock value and to be different but in the end it usually makes him look retarded
I think he is a fantastic evaluator.

He just blows at evaluating teams needs.
McShay is the Jamie Dukes of ESPN...who also thinks the Browns take Dez Bryant, lol wtf?
Originally posted by MaliCali:
McShay is the Jamie Dukes of ESPN...who also thinks the Browns take Dez Bryant, lol wtf?

I don't think that deserves a WTF. Bryant is a top 10 talent and the Browns have ZERO weapons.
Where is the production if he is so good?


Originally posted by Kalen49ers:
Originally posted by MaliCali:
McShay is the Jamie Dukes of ESPN...who also thinks the Browns take Dez Bryant, lol wtf?

I don't think that deserves a WTF. Bryant is a top 10 talent and the Browns have ZERO weapons.

massaqoi and robiske last year...they have talented young receivers, they dont have a quarterback.

taking bryant, with so many other needs that will definitely be available at 7 would definitely be a wtf.