Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
So many great Niner draft moments. I would guess it would be a toss up between:
Kentwan Balmer 2008
Alex Smith 2005
Rashaun Woods 2004
Kwame Harris 2003
Mike Rumph 2002
Gio Carmazzi 2000
Reggie McGrew 1999
RW McQuarters 1998
Jim Drukenmiller 1997
Israel Ifeanyi 1996
JJ Stokes 1995
Dana Hall 1992
Dexter Carter 1990
Keith Delong 1989
Daniel Stubbs 1988
Todd Shell 1984
Yes.. so many great Niner drat moments. OK.. so my final choice for the pick that still gets me SOOOO excited......... Jim I'm a Fricking Drunkenmiller
I will say the jury is still out on Balmer (he's got to come through this year though) and Alex Smith. You had a couple on your list that I wouldn't call "busts" in Stokes, Stubbs, Rumph and McQuarters. At least they did contribute for a year or two, and McQuarters actually had a decent career. We certainly didn't hit on some high profile linebackers though.
If you consider all those busts, than you probably also want to add Ted Washington and of course Jeff Bregel.
Point is that the draft is a crap shoot. I'm not sure I would ever trust a WR from
Oklahoma State again.
I think that if you went through alot of teams drafts over the same time period you'd see a lot of misses. Some of those earlier drafts were Bill Walsh and Seifert
drafts that we didn't hit on.
However, I think the combines and Pro Days would help diminish the misses but you are never certain.