There are 103 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

What NFL vet would you trade 1 of our 1st rounders for?

What NFL vet would you trade 1 of our 1st rounders for?

Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Originally posted by fly15:
Originally posted by crzy:
I'd trade both of our first rounders for Brandon Marshall. He's that good.

I agree he's good, but whos gonna pass it to him. cause our bust only plays for 2 qtrs. and he sucks.

how about kevin kolb from eagles??

If BMarsh made Cutler and Orton look good he can make Smith look good too dude.

ur funny.
but lets not get irritated, hopefully we'll get someone who can help the team. as much as i used 2 like smith, i hate 2 c him again in 2010.
  • Ether
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,494
Originally posted by fly15:
Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Originally posted by fly15:
Originally posted by crzy:
I'd trade both of our first rounders for Brandon Marshall. He's that good.

I agree he's good, but whos gonna pass it to him. cause our bust only plays for 2 qtrs. and he sucks.

how about kevin kolb from eagles??

If BMarsh made Cutler and Orton look good he can make Smith look good too dude.

ur funny.
but lets not get irritated, hopefully we'll get someone who can help the team. as much as i used 2 like smith, i hate 2 c him again in 2010.

What exactly was funny about his statement?
Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:
I'd consider it for Mankins. I mean if I had to choose between spending a 1st rounder on Iupati or a 28 year old guard who's made 80 of 80 NFL starts and two Pro-Bowls . . . not a hard choice.

Maybe not straight-up . . . say Mankins and a 4th in exchange for #17.

dude, It's really difficult for an O-lineman to continue to perform at a high level... blocking massive defensive tackles takes a heavy toll on the body. No way.
None of the above. Possibly Marshall if we signed at least 1 solid O-lineman via Free Agency.
Originally posted by dhp318:
Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:
I'd consider it for Mankins. I mean if I had to choose between spending a 1st rounder on Iupati or a 28 year old guard who's made 80 of 80 NFL starts and two Pro-Bowls . . . not a hard choice.

Maybe not straight-up . . . say Mankins and a 4th in exchange for #17.

dude, It's really difficult for an O-lineman to continue to perform at a high level... blocking massive defensive tackles takes a heavy toll on the body. No way.

Yeah I get that, but injuries can happen to anybody at any time. His NFL track record through five seasons suggests that he takes good care of his body and/or plays through pain.

I'd say he's got at least 5-7 seasons worth of high performance tread on the tires. I mean look at a guy like Larry Allen who was making Pro-Bowls into his 14th year. Mankins obviously isn't Larry Allen, but he's pretty clearly in the Faneca/Hutchinson realm.
Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:
Originally posted by dhp318:
Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:
I'd consider it for Mankins. I mean if I had to choose between spending a 1st rounder on Iupati or a 28 year old guard who's made 80 of 80 NFL starts and two Pro-Bowls . . . not a hard choice.

Maybe not straight-up . . . say Mankins and a 4th in exchange for #17.

dude, It's really difficult for an O-lineman to continue to perform at a high level... blocking massive defensive tackles takes a heavy toll on the body. No way.

Yeah I get that, but injuries can happen to anybody at any time. His NFL track record through five seasons suggests that he takes good care of his body and/or plays through pain.

I'd say he's got at least 5-7 seasons worth of high performance tread on the tires. I mean look at a guy like Larry Allen who was making Pro-Bowls into his 14th year. Mankins obviously isn't Larry Allen, but he's pretty clearly in the Faneca/Hutchinson realm.

Screw the Patriots and their development on rookies, they're too damn good. I wonder how David Baas or Adam Snyder would turned out if they drafted either one and developed them properly.
  • buck
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,859
Originally posted by saj4423:
none of the above

I have to agree.

Not sure what is happening, has happened, or will happpen in Denver, but I suspect that Brandon Marshall is not without blame for what is going on.

I want a ten-foot pole between him and the 49ers.
  • krizay
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 14,924
Originally posted by fly15:
Originally posted by crzy:
I'd trade both of our first rounders for Brandon Marshall. He's that good.

I agree he's good, but whos gonna pass it to him. cause our bust only plays for 2 qtrs. and he sucks.

how about kevin kolb from eagles??

Kolb, Bradford or Clausen or I'm already chalking 2010 up as a lost season!
Originally posted by buck:
Originally posted by saj4423:
none of the above

I have to agree.

Not sure what is happening, has happened, or will happpen in Denver, but I suspect that Brandon Marshall is not without blame for what is going on.

I want a ten-foot pole between him and the 49ers.

I wouldn't trade a 2nd round pick for any of those players.