Seems like both guys are at the end of their careers. McGahee did well early on, but seems to have totally replaced by Rice (which is not bad because I have Rice). Lewis hasn't been that effective this season, but it seems like a this point he's still probably good for 5-10 points a game. I wouldn't plan on starting either one of these guys. I'm just wondering which would be better to keep around in case there's an injury to one of my starting RBs. I'm in a 12 team league, so even guys like Moats and Snelling are taken.
I'm leaning towards Lewis, because I think he'll probably put up more points over the rest of the season.
What's your take?